If some FromSoft game wants to crack it into the top 3, it needs to not have stinky bosses/aspects.
Sekiro had the Demon of Hatred, and the portion after the second invasion of Ashina are stinkers.
However other than that, this is the closest FromSoft has gotten to have a combat system that would rival a cinematic trailer while maintaining agency (well assuming you're good at the game anyway). I'm going to cheat and put it in the same place as DS1 aka top 3. Two top 3s.
Sekiro had the Demon of Hatred, and the portion after the second invasion of Ashina are stinkers.
However other than that, this is the closest FromSoft has gotten to have a combat system that would rival a cinematic trailer while maintaining agency (well assuming you're good at the game anyway). I'm going to cheat and put it in the same place as DS1 aka top 3. Two top 3s.