Flawed, but I kinda love it regardless, and in a perfect world it probably could have been my favorite of the series. So many parts of this SHOULD make it so; it has the most vile atmosphere out of any of the Silent Hill games I've played, the way it plays with the concept of a safe room is brilliant, and everything regarding Walter Sullivan is so good until you actually play it and it's just alright I guess. At the very least it's basically just a better version of The Evil Within, and I do greatly appreciate how different this one was in comparison to other Silent Hill sequels (especially 3), it's clear Team Silent had plenty of new ideas that just sadly weren't fully executed.