Replaying it again in 2024, with the PC port, I could confirm that this was indeed a masterpiece. There's some flaws, of course, like some animations taking too long and the underwhelming epilogue/cut content, but the way the story is handled, how beautiful the game is even after 4 years of release with its beautiful landscapes and amazing character models/animations, the dialogue, the immersion of playing in a 1900's America, everything. Arthur Morgan is also one of the best protagonists in gaming as well, he is excellently written. Just an excellent game.