Even graded on a curve, this is rough. There are elements of the game that are undeniably cool, and within the context of the game's release, having a mech game like this that leaned away from the simulation elements of games like Battletech was a good call. It was a frustrating game, but also one that has enough ways to be broken that the frustration doesn't prevent progress.

Also it gave Kota Hoshino a job. He'd go on to do much better stuff, but you can see his style of composition at work already. The mech designs/settings/atmosphere in general are better than I expected, even if what would come after would stick with me more.

I can't suggest playing this game unless you're a completionist of the series, but going back to the game will be easier than you expect (although a guide will save you a ton of time).

Reviewed on Sep 02, 2023


2 Comments


14 days ago

hoshino actually didn't get involved until master of arena. not to discredit 1/pp's soundtracks though - they're still good

also the mech designs are better than you expected because the series mechanical designer is the dude who created macross (shoji kawamori)

13 days ago

oh I didn't know that! the OST I grabbed credits him for AC1, it must have been a metadata issue

I didn't know that at all! They're such distinctive mech designs, the only ones that stick out more to me are from Phantom Crash/SLAI.