My first souls game. I enjoyed the tone and world, and especially the challenges. However, sometimes I feel that the game opts for spectacle over fairness, and some of the boss encounters are a bit clunky in that aspect. Awaiting the DLC!
The perfect horde shooter. I don't imagine there will be any game that tops this. There is absolutely zero in-game progression "systems" and yet it is absolutely worthy of hundreds, maybe thousands, over hours.