Bland, frustrating and sloppy. Poor presentation and level design sours the authentic feeling of Classic 2D Sonic movement mechanics. Bosses waste your time for minutes on end, and while I've yet to try the co-op, it seems to be completely broken. It's criminal that this is being sold for $95 AUD.

Emerald powers feel borderline useless outside of a few exceptions, and the Special Stages are just awful. They're a cool idea on paper - swinging around to build momentum towards the Emerald, but are just a chore to play.

Oh and also, the spindash doesn't work properly if your refresh rate is set to above 60FPS, so I had to turn off Vsync and change it manually in the options, only to suffer from screen-tearing. Very cool! And it's just running from an Epic Games Store version within Steam, I guess? Freaking epic.

Go buy Sonic Mania instead - it looks, sounds and plays better in every way. Even the reused levels are more original than just about anything in Superstars, except for maybe its final act. Glad I didn't buy this.

Reviewed on Oct 17, 2023


4 Comments


6 months ago

@Markostyrkes Perhaps the game deserves such negativity (esp. when many issues mentioned could be avoided pretty easily)

6 months ago

good review, sorry you're getting jumped on twitter lol

6 months ago

@luminosity ikr? mfs were really trying to use the fact that he family shared the game against him. like how desperate do you gotta be when someone insults your game 😭

6 months ago

Ok UnderTheMayo