So, let's talk about Persona 4, shall we? In my humble opinion, its strongest suit is hands down its characters. The Dojimas absolutely steal the show with top-notch writing and amazing social links. It's funny, though—those characters don't have shadows, and maybe that's why they stand out so much as amazing parts. Shadows are supposed to be all about accepting yourself and facing your true beliefs (Which is completely ripped away for no reason later on in Namatames shadow, being the beliefs of the public instead of your true beliefs), but ultimately they just end up as character assassinations once you do their respective social links. Dungeons are… okay. Some are utter garbage in their theming such as Naoto’s and Kanji’s. Aside from that their okay, with a stellar dungeon for the culprit. So, is Persona 4 a masterpiece? Nah, not in my book. Is it the ultimate JRPG gem? Nope. But does it offer a cozy, feel-good ride with awesome characters and a decent theme? Mhm. Overall, I had a great time with it.

I had the feeling that this was the best version of the visuals on P4 and...imo I feel I was kinda right.
Sure, P4G got re-enhanced with 60fps and some QoLs, but the game engine and some visuals effects (especially the fog) feels much more...natural here?

Never been a huge fan of P4 (and never probably will).
While I liked many parts of the game, especially about the villain, I can't stand Chie, Yukiko and Teddie still.

Gameplay feels good, but this felt like the most boring entry by far, tartarus is something I have to lightly grind for as well as full moon's in p3, and palaces felt like they didn't overstay their welcome bar one particular exception.

Plus no super duper easy let me just play through the story mode unlike p4g, say what you will about how dungeon crawling is important to the game I'm gonna use hours I saved not killing the same shadows in a dungeon over and over again to file my taxes or something.