Fun combat and fantastic music locked behind an unfortunately bland experience. Given the general lack of creativity in the Mario brand around the time, as well as Paper Mario practically being on deaths door following Sticker Star, what could have been a great merger between two beloved RPG series instead just kinda came out... eh.
This review contains spoilers
This game was nice, it was good to see a Mario x Paper Mario crossover but I feel like this game has a lot of missed potential.
Recycling Neo Bowser Castle name was not cool, I appreciated that there were the koopalings but Iggy, Morton and Lemmy bossfight was just a oneshot thingy, I'd have enjoyed to see more. But in the end it wasn't a bad game at all!
Recycling Neo Bowser Castle name was not cool, I appreciated that there were the koopalings but Iggy, Morton and Lemmy bossfight was just a oneshot thingy, I'd have enjoyed to see more. But in the end it wasn't a bad game at all!
I'm honestly super glad this game didn't end being a giant fan-fictiony pandering crossover fuckfest with no rhyme or reason like most people wanted (for some reason) but I think the story ends up on the opposite side of that extreme, which is being too standard and safe. It's not bad by any means, it's just generic as all hell. That doesn't really matter though cuz this is still an M&L game, meaning it still has fun gameplay, an amazing battle system, charming dialogue, a great soundtrack, and oodles of charm. Tmw when the "worst" Mario & Luigi game is still really good. I miss this series, dude...
Paper Jam is quite the mixed bag in the series. A game absolutely brimming with comedy and fun, Paper Jam unfortunately lacks a lot of what made older titles so special to so many people: the worlds. The Mario & Luigi series so much represents the fun of adventuring unknown worlds, as each game applies this key factor in many interesting and creative ways, which really hurts Paper Jam in so many ways. When it comes to combat and systems, Paper Jam is as smooth and as, well, Mario & Luigi as you can find.
They get the two versions of Mario with great storytelling to come together...and it's a generic 'Save the Princess' story: in a fucking Mario RPG!!!?!?!?!? That is the lamest shit ever! Well, the gameplay is refined, especially on more complex difficulties. Paper Mario is a great companion for using special attacks with or pairing in the group. Play this if you want, but pick ANY OTHER M&L or Paper Mario RPG other than this.
Garbage. This game is literally a crime.
I could've ended off here, but it now falls on me to do the explaining. Mario and Luigi was once a masterful Mario RPG subseries made by the late Alphadream that Nintendo used as an excuse to ruin Paper Mario, on the pretense that they already had a Mario RPG series, and wanted to do something different with Paper Mario, hence transforming Paper Mario into Paper Jam with Sticker Star. This resulted in a dangerous loop for both series ironically, where Paper Mario was mortified into a zombie looking even creepier than Doopliss, and Mario and Luigi was left on life support for a few years, before dying off thanks to this piece of garbage, Mario and Luigi: Paper Jam. A game that was supposed to marry both beloved subseries together, only stifled creative liberty by destroying everything that made Mario and Luigi great via jamming Paper Jam's solace and stupidity into the forefront. The rich storytelling of MandL was completely axed in favor of yet another Paper Jam story, where two Bowsers act in tandem to do evil things for the umpteenth time, intruding on a series whose first main antagonist wasn't even Bowser. Give the Koopa King a break, writers. He deserves better than this.
Despite the gameplay very much being Mario and Luigi, the tone and feeling is again severely corrupted. The gameplay is still fun and I would give this abomination a 5/10 just for having fantastic gameplay if it hadn't crushed Mario and Luigi with it. Paper Jam is the reason Alphadream went bankrupt, because this game was so unappealing and antithetical to a subseries whose creative status was untouched, so it had to be destroyed for the greater good according to Nintendo. This is why Paper Mario should've never been ruined, because its influence is what destroyed Mario and Luigi to begin with.
I could've ended off here, but it now falls on me to do the explaining. Mario and Luigi was once a masterful Mario RPG subseries made by the late Alphadream that Nintendo used as an excuse to ruin Paper Mario, on the pretense that they already had a Mario RPG series, and wanted to do something different with Paper Mario, hence transforming Paper Mario into Paper Jam with Sticker Star. This resulted in a dangerous loop for both series ironically, where Paper Mario was mortified into a zombie looking even creepier than Doopliss, and Mario and Luigi was left on life support for a few years, before dying off thanks to this piece of garbage, Mario and Luigi: Paper Jam. A game that was supposed to marry both beloved subseries together, only stifled creative liberty by destroying everything that made Mario and Luigi great via jamming Paper Jam's solace and stupidity into the forefront. The rich storytelling of MandL was completely axed in favor of yet another Paper Jam story, where two Bowsers act in tandem to do evil things for the umpteenth time, intruding on a series whose first main antagonist wasn't even Bowser. Give the Koopa King a break, writers. He deserves better than this.
Despite the gameplay very much being Mario and Luigi, the tone and feeling is again severely corrupted. The gameplay is still fun and I would give this abomination a 5/10 just for having fantastic gameplay if it hadn't crushed Mario and Luigi with it. Paper Jam is the reason Alphadream went bankrupt, because this game was so unappealing and antithetical to a subseries whose creative status was untouched, so it had to be destroyed for the greater good according to Nintendo. This is why Paper Mario should've never been ruined, because its influence is what destroyed Mario and Luigi to begin with.