Why would you play this when you can play Downpour on the same system? At least that game feels like it respects Silent Hill. The worst part is that this game isn't even that bad, it just has such a tonal inconsistency, such a repetative story and such a clear want to just reproduce Silent Hill 2 but with none of the interesting characters or story-world interplay. The only redeeming feature of this game is that it is finishable and the puzzles aren't too frustrating (except the final one), but even then it's only if you can contend with the bugs, especially on PC.