By far the best part of this game is how well it captures each era of film it represents, it is really something to behold. I also greatly enjoyed most of the acting, with special regard to Manon Gage who steals the show.
I also can't help but personally feel that this is Barlow's most bloated game, with a much higher ratio of FMV clips that drag or feel unneeded. And maybe as a symptom of that, I personally think they could have stood to push you more toward relevant clips to some of the plot's core threads when you're imminently unraveling them.
As a whole, I came away positive and I definitely think it's a game worth trying, especially if you like film, and the less you know beforehand the better!