its better than the zeebo port, i guess.

this remake is an exercise in futility. almost everything new is bad and everything good about it is from a 20 year old game that remains superior to this. part of what made the original special is that it was isolated from the rest of the franchise, and in every sense of the word this remake's number one priority is to homogenize it with everything else while still being "resident evil 4" in the most half-hearted, pathetic way possible.

the tone of this game wants so desperately to be melodramatic and self-serious in line with the other remakes but understands that it loses all appeal if it doesnt still portray RE4-isms, so in one scene nu-leon will say "Fuck... this has to be different... shit..." and in the very next he'll do The Bingo Line or go "Whoopsy daisy, looks like I just kicked you in the head" a million times during combat because otherwise it won't get a 4.6 average on Backloggd. it wants to be new but feels to obligated to be old because it is literally a remake so the entire thing feels wholly disingenuous.

resident evil 4 was also an action game and the modern RE remakes are more of an exercise in frustration than anything, so nu-4 tries to mix both worlds without really having the engine to back it up. the amount of times leon would be stunlocked by an enemy breathing on him is enough to make a man insane, and the enemy states in this game are also much more vague than the original. the idea is that if you should them in the head or leg you can perform a melee, but sometimes enemies just wont be affected by these things at all and the player is left entirely out of control.

there are plenty of new additions that fans of a PS2 action game are sure to love also, such as
- Cut content sold later as DLC
- Weapon degredation, and speaking of which
- Stealth Kills (who asked for this)
- Parries (but dont use them, because your knife will break. also the game makes it super unclear what you can and cannot parry besides having a brief parry prompt in the corner, so its as if the game still has quick time events)
- That thing where instead of mashing to get out of grabs, you just stab them. This is really pointless since it also breaks your knife but enemies grab you so much more here that fuck it, you can have my knife
- Iconic new Side Quests such as "kill 3 rats" and "kill 3 snakes"
- Unlockable charms that give wonderful bonuses like 5% higher chance of enemies dropping green herbs or shotgun bullets
- A crouch button(??)
- A new enemy thats practically the same as Salvador but more frequent and nearly unstaggerable so hes really just an ammo toll, thanks

this game is just so phony in so many ways. lots of little things are worse. the regenerator music is louder and they become a standard enemy instead of having their own special moments. characters talk more and have less to say. arguably every single boss encounter is more "cinematic" instead of being dynamic, like Mendez hiding in the background to pick up big red barrels for you to shoot instead of just being a boss fight. the game in general is more cinematic and even has one of those fucking sequences where you just hold up on the left stick while a psuedo-cutscene plays. in MY resident evil 4

i fail to see any way that this remake is trying to do anything besides rewrite history, let alone one of the most historically significant games ever made. i shudder to think of the amount of people who will say "resident evil 4" in reference to this and this alone. it does wimpily try to emulate the original, so it can still have its moments, but otherwise adds positively nothing to the industry and has effectively only harmed the reputation of the 2005 game. im glad people love it as much as they do, and i wish so dearly that they would be inspired to see what the original is all about too, but chances of that are low. this is new, and thats old. morir es vivir, morir es vivir

Reviewed on Mar 28, 2023


6 Comments


1 year ago

Gonna print 100 copies of this review and staple it to telephone poles all over the city
You were right the first time bro

1 year ago

@BigBossHayabusa in many ways i was and i still absolutely seethe at the response this game gets because i was entirely correct about general audiences rewriting this as wha RE4 always was, but i also cant lie that on repeat playthroughs i just have some damn fun kicking people in the head. the games industry has been so dire for so long that i have to recognize that at the end of the day this is a fun video game and walk away with that, even if thinking about the morals of it makes me want to spit on the ground

1 year ago

No goddamnit we need to demand better than this lol

1 year ago

@DJSCheddar no youre absolutely right, if this were the last remake to ever come out i would be clicking my heels in impish delight, but the fact is this game was always going to exist thanks to industry trends (trends which capcom themselves sparked with RE2.) general audiences care so little about video games that they will continue to demand remakes and studios will never have any reason not to give it to them, so the only recourse is to either not engage with most new games (a very valid path that i am shackled to never take) or try and get the most out of what comes out of otherwise talented studios like crapcom. like i said, as far as AAA games go, this is still leaps and bounds better than most releases even if its working off a cheat sheet. we should demand more valuable art from the medium, youre right, but until someone has the balls to make it we wont get it. das da biznes, babey

1 year ago

@MultiGenre Fair, and well said. Myself, I'm already well on that first path you mentioned. But godspeed, friendo