@Yoav 3.5 is a good score. Parts of the game are empty and it's story doesn't do anything notably new for me. I can't just ignore Yado's plan and the flash because the game's entire story is built off it. Brad's story itself is interesting, but nothing that I haven't seen before.

Omori came out long after Lisa and handles completely different subject matter so they have nothing to do with each other. I only mention it because hadn't I played Omori prior, I likely would have looked at this game more favorably. Since Omori is a tighter and more focused game that leaves almost nothing unaddressed, Lisa's unaddressed plot-holes stand out more notably.