Is my rating too high? Probably. I know that the gameplay is not perfect and the graphics were never the best.
Nevertheless I LOVE this game. It's an important part of my childhood and it made me love the western genre in general. The story is nothing special, but the atmosphere is absolutely stunning if you love old spaghetti westerns: story elements, gun sounds, character types, level design and the fantastic soundtrack (almost all pieces are straight out of several B-western movies made in italy). All these components constitute the quality of this -unjustly- unknown little gem.