Persona 4 is a very good persona game, just not as good as 3 and 5.

Story is solid, but I think it was a gigantic plot fail that literally the entire investigation team, a team solving a murder case, is stupid. It was crazy how naoto literally carried every conversation with actual reasoning while yosuke and chie yelled at eachother and kanji just yelled at nothing.
I couldn't stand half the investigation team honestly, yosuke and teddie sexual harassment got really really old really really fast.

I fucked up getting the true ending, nothing hurts more than seeing fake credits and realising i didn't jingle the tree spirits balls and decline the yes or no to ending the game so that i can hit the flag for the actual ending, not spending like 3 hours going back just to watch a cutscene and read a novel of dialogue.

Overall, needs a remake I would say, if the game got the level of style and polish of Reload, I think it'd be 5 stars.