some of the tightest character writing since stay/night, though i think that the villain-of-the-week format of this holy grail war denies most of the cast the depth you'd expect (or desire) out of a successor to said story. unfortunately said format means the plot structure is pretty rote and repetitive without much in the way of divergence from its own linearity, which isn't easily overlooked considering the lackluster ending of the only character arc that really gets any room to breathe: the protagonist's.

also, probably the single worst combat system i've ever had to deal with in a jrpg. rng is always bad game design in my book, but basing your combat almost exclusively around it is pretty much unforgivable.

Reviewed on Jun 12, 2023


3 Comments


9 months ago

Admittedly I've done more wikidives than actually playing it but I feel like the structure of the writing is kind of the point; F/SN was about Emiya extrapolating info from your peers and either perservering or emboldening them from their actions/behaviors in the face of uncertainty and adversity, Extra goes in a different angle by implanting Hakuno and their servant's past and current predicament under scrutiny as you unveil this Grail War's setting and diatrabes with all that's going on. Granted, it doesn't excuse everything, but idk I found it cool so far. Like how character interactions work too.

Also the RPS system is something I'm glad exists if only cause of how batshit of an idea it is, and how not even a guide that literally lists out all potential patterns to eke the win out will work 100%. It's fucked up but kind of hilarious to see in action.

9 months ago

@blazingwaters I don't disagree that it all works in service of Hakuno and their characterization but since I absolutely hate the way their story ends everything else falls apart since all the other things I think are lackluster about F/EX are more acceptable in the context of laying the foundation for Hakuno's development as a character

9 months ago

That's fair, was really just giving my piece on it. I would say more but again, wikidiver and I only played up to the fight w/ Rider so I can't add anything meaningful. Most I can say now is tht I like the vibes and the OST provided by Shinji Hosoe. That's a banger right there.

Wish we got more info about the remake rn cause I'm pretty curious to know if they'll add much to it, also if they're gonna keep the Arcueid and Ryougi cameos...