Typically when rating a game or movie or any subject for that matter, I think about my enjoyment, the quality and other things but the main reason for me giving this specific CoD the highest rating possible is due to one simple reason that I always ask myself right before judging something. I'll frame it like this, when looking at Call of Duty as a whole, could it get any better or any worse than this specific one? The answer to me is only yes to one side of that question. This is the quintessential Call of Duty game, in every aspect. The best campaign, best gameplay, best maps in multiplayer and zombies, best dlc, maybe it's nostalgia that propels this to a higher tier or maybe it's just that good. In reality, it's probably a mix of both, but i'll be damned if I lowered it's rating for that or any other reason. If you only play one CoD, it'd be more than wise to make it this one.
Black Ops is a perfect game. Perfect campaign, multiplayer, and especially Zombies. There's Nuketown, Jungle, Summit and other great maps in the multiplayer. And the Zombies, is the best thing to exist. First, it's even a bigger improvement to WaW. Second, the maps were the greatest. Kino Der Toten, Five, Dead Ops Arcade, Ascension, Moon were all great maps. It's the Call of Duty dream for everybody.
Activision continues their string of successes with BO coming just short of the peaks that MW2 reached.
An interesting thought about the series as a whole, and helps to explain why I still rank MW2 above this one, albeit slightly, is that up until the first Modern Warfare, the games played closest to like a war movie, Saving Private Ryan, Band of Brothers, that type of stuff. After Modern Warfare though, the series takes this turn into just straight action flicks, your Heat, Shoot Em Ups, John Wick, just fast paced action. Now while those concepts might not seem entirely separate, they definitely are as you can see Treyarch trying to kind of combine the two concepts with this game and WaW, while Infinity Ward just leans fully into the action tropes. It's a small difference, but it's that commitment that makes those games slightly edge out their other entries.
An interesting thought about the series as a whole, and helps to explain why I still rank MW2 above this one, albeit slightly, is that up until the first Modern Warfare, the games played closest to like a war movie, Saving Private Ryan, Band of Brothers, that type of stuff. After Modern Warfare though, the series takes this turn into just straight action flicks, your Heat, Shoot Em Ups, John Wick, just fast paced action. Now while those concepts might not seem entirely separate, they definitely are as you can see Treyarch trying to kind of combine the two concepts with this game and WaW, while Infinity Ward just leans fully into the action tropes. It's a small difference, but it's that commitment that makes those games slightly edge out their other entries.