Reviews from

in the past


sinnoh is kind of the goat region i will not be taking criticism at this time thanks

GooeyScale: 90/100

This review contains spoilers

Me gusta el diseño del personaje principal y de los otros aqui, aunque es curioso que simplemente cojan y les pongan bufandas xd. Gracias a dios el orden de los gimnasios ahora es mas lineal. El orden de Perla y Diamante me daba un poquito de TOC. Es un poquito mas rapido, pero creo que se exagera. Y el mundo distorsión está bastante bien por lo que hasta la fecha sigue siendo de las locaciones mas unicas de la saga.

Sinnoh lore is pretty cool. Also has my favorite music out of the mainline games. Just a great game in general.

The levelling is all over the place at times (wild pokemon can be way too underleveled and trainer pokemon too overleveled), the pokedex isn't nearly diverse enough, and there are WAY TOO MANY HMS however in the grand scheme of things these are my only problems and they're pretty minor. I adore everything else about this game the gameplay is phenomenal, sinnoh is a great region, and that soundtrack dude...


This is the one that actually changed our brain chemistry irrevocably. If we're being "objective" this is probably a 4-star because of the dogwater pacing, but also, FUCK objectivity + didn't ask + we have a 10 year old Cookie Clicker save and we didn't get that way without having the patience of a saint + at least we admit that we gave this one 5 stars because it's the one that impacted child us the most!

...Also we love Luxray.

Literally the perfect gen 4 game

It’s Pokémon DP except Pokémon Satan gets a new form and more battle facilities.

It’s great obviously but it really should have came out a year after the originals, I just can’t feel compelled to give it a perfect score for 2 years of waiting.

Pokemon Platinum gave me the devil of Pokemon mythology and I think that's awesome.

The height of all pokemon games

This game has problems a lot of people don't mention (lack of Pokemon variety, version exclusives from Diamond and Pearl being missing, etc,) but this is the best way to experience Sinnoh. Classic game, super nostalgic.

Gameplay padrão e divertida dos jogos pokemons que tem seus diferenciais em cada versão um otimo jogo também que me deixou traumas de um certo Garchomp

This is as close as my casual gamer instincts have gotten to those of a more hardcore gamer. I love this game. It's nostalgic in a way very few games are for me. Also, gen 4 has the best pokemon design don't @ me.

pokemon needs to become darker, it needs guns, and drugs. this shit looks dark, but its for fucking kids and that pisses me the fuck off

Among the best Pokémon games you can play. Awesome soundtrack, fantastic region.

hmdl je l'ai dans ma collection

An improvement on Diamond and Pearl in nearly every way.

Me when there's more than two fire types this time around (😱)

Took me a while to finish because of school and that might have impacted my opinion on it.
I thought it was a fine pokemon game, but it didn't take me in that much. The gameplay is solid and the new pokemon are very good, but I'm too used to them for it to really matter. In fact a significant problem I had, which isn't really the game's fault to be fair, was that I arleady knew a lot about what was gonna happen, just like I already knew the pokemon. For example the distortion world would have blown my mind, but I had already seen it plenty of times. My biggest criticism is how slow the game is, I used 2x speed for probably hours and even then progressing through some parts still felt impossible.

platinum? the average valorant player can barely shoot

Don’t think I really found this one as affecting in some ways. LOVED making poffins and dicking about in the underground though!!!

one of the games i am most nostalgic for, and also the only pokemon i have enjoyed. i need to make sure i don't listen to this games music, otherwise embarrassing memories will start spilling out. i was so young when i played this, i never could access the online connectivity features and it made me think there was some kind of magic or hidden technology involved. i still don't know what was up with all that underground base stuff. going into giratinas home felt like i was really doing something i wasnt supposed to be doing. it was awesome.

Acho que foi um dos Pokémon mais recentes que eu joguei, e gostei, achei bem desafiador e tem uma ótima vibe que só a era de DS/3DS tem


Peak level design with really good and rewarding dungeons, gradual growth in difficulty and among the best pokemon designs, shame on them for deciding to remove a good amount of current gen pokemon from the game and leaving a limiting a lot of them with trade based evolutions or ID based encounters, greatly reducing the pool of choice for the team. Still one of the best pokemon games.

Assez injouable aujourd'hui mais c'est toute mon enfance donc note pas objective