RE2 does a really good job with the horror vibe, it's somewhat diminished on the B playthrough though because not a great amount changes between characters. The Ada section sucked and the Sherry section wasn't great but it's opening was really good and did a good job with the horror vibe. Weapon variety is good but the hitboxes for some of the attacks feel a bit unfair, especially with stage 2 G. Really good game all in all though, shooting and movement feel really good, dialogue and story are good, nice graphics, mostly okay PC port.
The pinnacle of the franchise and the best horror game I've ever seen, Resident Evil 2 remake takes everything the franchise has done best and elevates it to perfection, with a terrifying atmosphere, beautiful graphics, excellent gameplay, and a very competent story, for me, the true game of the year of 2019, although I also love Sekiro.
A couple years ago I binged the entire RE series up to 6 as I had never played RE before and got very invested. I played the original RE2 a long while before getting around to this game and during that time, I realized I was more a fan of the "classic style" RE versus the "middle era" (4/5/Rev1), and modern era. I tell myself that if RE2 had a remake in the same vein as REmake, it would hands down be my absolute favorite. RE2R, while fantastic in its retelling of RE2, environments, atmosphere, puzzle-solving, etc., I find myself somehow not liking it more than the original. Its hard for me to really understand why, seeing as this is a substantial improvement, and I can admit that. I did end up, after completing the main stories, trying out the extra modes and despising every one of them, so its possible they left a sour taste in my mouth. But all the same, I guess subconsciously, I'm nostalgic for the gameplay of the first 5 entries. Don't mistake my opinion of this game though, I really did love it, just slightly less than the original