Dorogogogo
It took about three years for me to "get" this game after trying several times. It grinds down your rough edges to razor-sharp perfection, and by the end of it I certainly felt like I had shinobi reflexes like your boy Wolf. For the first time since Dark Souls 3 (my first FROMSoft experience), this game teased out those dearest emotions: frustration, ecstasy, and a hunger to improve, almost exclusively through its gameplay. The story it has to tell is uncharacteristically (for this dev team) direct, and cuts as deep as the Mortal Blade if you engage with the characters.
Phenomenal game, and makes the player work for it, even moreso than more traditional FROMSoft titles. Probably the only game in their lineup that is actually about as inaccessible as the fanbase makes it sound, at least in my experience, but rewarding and refined like few other action games can even hope to be. There are games I personally like more than this, but for what this game is trying to be (shinobi power fantasy accurate to the strengths of that archetype) it's effectively perfect, if perhaps more narrowly-focused than its established Souls-like contemporaries.
Phenomenal game, and makes the player work for it, even moreso than more traditional FROMSoft titles. Probably the only game in their lineup that is actually about as inaccessible as the fanbase makes it sound, at least in my experience, but rewarding and refined like few other action games can even hope to be. There are games I personally like more than this, but for what this game is trying to be (shinobi power fantasy accurate to the strengths of that archetype) it's effectively perfect, if perhaps more narrowly-focused than its established Souls-like contemporaries.
2004
2011
this game is carried by its writing and setting, both of which are literally derivative of Sapkowski's novels. that said, as an interactive chapter of Geralt's story in a well-realized version of the northern realms, this game is phenomenal. Novigrad is one of the most fascinating places I've had the pleasure of experiencing, and feels authentic in a way I didn't think games could at the time. Geralt himself is also in peak form, and the way he responds to the world is endlessly entertaining and engaging.
the combat is a dumpster fire in a rusty dumpster. i bounced off of the Witcher 2 three separate times due to its combat, and this game is only slightly better on that front. when it works, it looks cool, but that's it. never once did i feel like i was in control of any element of a battle, since attacks are still the coding equivalent of guess-work in how they relate to animations. played as a casual narrative, this game is at its best.
also Geralt and Ciri finally get to have the depth of companionship they should have to reflect the books and it's delightful.
the combat is a dumpster fire in a rusty dumpster. i bounced off of the Witcher 2 three separate times due to its combat, and this game is only slightly better on that front. when it works, it looks cool, but that's it. never once did i feel like i was in control of any element of a battle, since attacks are still the coding equivalent of guess-work in how they relate to animations. played as a casual narrative, this game is at its best.
also Geralt and Ciri finally get to have the depth of companionship they should have to reflect the books and it's delightful.
i'd like this a lot more if it ran well and had better partner AI for exploration. unfortunately my memory of this game is dominated by my tethered dragon getting stuck pathfinding through elevated geometry like a despondent sibling in a 2D beat-em-up.
this one just makes me more sad than anything else.
this one just makes me more sad than anything else.
2018
2021