Honestly really good; the story is above average and the gameplay feels nice, although the weapon selection is very limited. The biggest problem is that it takes place in this huge open world, but it's so faithful of a remake of the original Mafia that it's painfully linear for this type of setting.

good, but the cut content from the original is disappointing

fun gameplay loop, interesting story, obnoxious writing, terrible last two bosses, pretty good music

some of the same problems as the old crash games but otherwise just as good as them, sometimes better

the final boss was pretty terrible

otherwise mostly quite good