Marshmelio
2006
2003
2011
2021
my feelings on this are similar to the original. It changed part of my life (in this case, I started learning Japanese to read it), but I'm left unsatisfied. I think it was an awful move to release only the near side routes, and while there's ton of improvement in comparison to the original (though there are a few losses too), I still don't really care about this side of tsukihime. The only thing I took away from it was Noel, I really liked her.
I came in expecting something similar to Higurashi in its structure, so I was left disappointed. None about this is any fun, and ryukishi's writing feels like filler because this is a chore to read through. Not a single fun character, not a single fun fight, it's just the damn mystery which the story doesn't really make you care about personally, you just clinically try solving it because it's the point of the story.
2000