Gripping combination of strategy and life sim only marred by a few design flaws:
+ numerous well-written conversations between the entire cast facilitating character developments
+ polished combat system with endless possibilities for customization
+ great variety of likable personalities to interact with
+ remarkable replayability factor due to four relatively distinct routes
- ugly backgrounds and stiff character animation in cutscenes
- several balancing issues concerning classes
- decent story presented in an unimpressive manner
- reused maps and tedious hub area by the end
- very rigid gameplay structure filled with repetitive activities

2016

A brief artistic experience that makes a lasting impression in just a couple of hours:
+ marvelously stylized graphics with outstanding use of colors
+ both mystical and vibrant set pieces
+ unique presentation of marine life
+ fitting orchestral soundtrack
- slightly frustrating camera and controls
- uninteresting story
- limited replayability due to its linearity and lack of player involvement

Short and sweet action adventure that makes for an engaging experience in the superhero universe:
+ very fun cast of characters
+ innovatively empowering combat system that feels fluid if unpolished
+ great pacing facilitated by the small setting and minimal backtracking
+ immersive atmosphere blending comedy and horror
+ surprisingly good graphics outside of cutscenes
- for the most part badly designed boss fights
- poorly implemented detective vision (almost indispensable yet makes everything look worse)
- ultimately unsatisfying narrative with many unfinished plot threads

2014

A fun-to-play if shallow stealth action adventure:
+ smooth movement mechanics
+ atmospheric presentation most of the time
+ barely passable narrative
- simplistic and unvaried gameplay
- unrealistic and cramped environments harming both strategy and immersion

Well-rounded JRPG with several outstanding elements:
+ a unique setting that inspires a sense of awe with its grand scale and imaginative environments
+ incredible soundtrack in both variety and impact
+ competent story driven forward by a likable cast
+ appreciated character customization
+ solid visual presentation particularly in action cutscenes
+ worthwhile epilogue DLC included
+ enjoyable if simple combat system
- grinding required even on normal difficulty
- significant time spent walking only
- numerous exclusively uninteresting side quests