A lot of people don't like this because it's an even edgier spin off game, but it still 100% holds up and I've come back to it every couple years since it came out.
To this day this is still my favorite Pokémon game. It might be a lot of nostalgia, but me and my dad played through this together and it was just awesome. Looking back, I was really a sucker for cool shit.
Absolutely beautiful experience. If ot weren't for a couple slightly obtuse clues it would probably be perfect. Haven't played it with the DLC yet, so maybe it is perfect by now.