Saccharine and dream-like without deliberately ignoring the harshness of reality that spurs on those idle fantasies. Since it's a period piece of sorts (set around the time of Barack Obama's first electoral win) there's plenty of anachronisms you could nitpick, but what I think it gets best is the hypocrisy of the era -- that empty hope for something better that we all know never really came. There's lots of "unrealistic" aspects baked into the experience, and I feel a nitpick would probably be that all the characters feel distinctly queer, but I also magically ended up being friends with a bunch of closeted queer people circa 2008, ones I'm still friends with to this day! And like, depending on the era the story is taking place in, the characters might act a little older than you'd expect for people of that age (both in the elementary school flashbacks and the "modern" high school perspective), but it fits so well into the game's themes, premise, and ultimately the fantasy that Butterfly Soup is trying to deliver that it's not even a legitimate criticism in my eyes.

The humor definitely seems hit or miss for some people, but I thought it was cute!! The most accurate "child-like" aspect of the characters the writing lands is their sense of humor and it honestly rules for that; I definitely knew people like and was friends with people like Akarsha in middle and high school. Plus, there's just genuinely snappy humor goin' on here (in the end though it was the "Mile 'Tails' Edgeworth" that really got me, probably because that's exactly the type of joke me and my friends would've made back in like 2009).

Butterfly Soup is just a really lovely visual novel, I think more people should check it out if it interests them!!! Also, I am definitely not beating the Min allegations.

I accidentally took a class with my least favorite professor for a second time Spring 2018. I had taken rhetorical studies with him Spring 2017 and it was the worst class of my entire college career. When I arrived in class January 2018 and saw this professor my heart sunk. His classes were boring and unfocused. I played Butterfly Soup during this second class, and it was infinitely better than listening to this professor drone on. I didn't play it with sound on because I was in class, but the game was so good without sound that I didn't feel like I needed it.

Visual novel focusing on topics of growing up, gender identity, sexual orientation, anxiety, stereotypical terrible Asian parents, and some baseball. I really didn't like the beginning but liked it more as it went on, it can do a good job bringing up it's subjects. I didn't really like any of the characters but Diya partly from more characterization for her than most of the other three characters, her less overblown ridiculous moments, and focus on her anxiety. I'm not a fan of the more ridiculous moments which basically all come from one character but I think that's equaled out by the enjoyment I get from seeing stories focused on women or groups not usually focused on or my enjoyment of seeing women not date men. It's short with a sudden ending. Choices aren't really necessary. Little time is spent with one of the main characters when it comes to her family, past, or any changes she goes through.

Don't go into this game expecting a deep world with detailed lore and backstories. There are other visual novels for that. This game was made to give people a nice warm feeling and a sense of familiarity.

That being said, this was a lovely kinetic novel about four girls who play baseball, and how their identities and personalities intersect with each other and play into other parts of their lives. It is a love letter to young lesbians and bisexual girls of all backgrounds, and a beautiful one at that.

It’s nice to see Butterfly Soup high school nostalgic tale not because it’s more or less accurate (who knows) but because it believes in a teenage ideal where being yourself is accepted and received with love. It’s a letter of hope. Even if the world opposes you, even if your parents oppose you, you can find that group of friends that will understand you. The ideal of Butterfly Soup is not one where all hardships around you magically disappear, but one where the rebellious spirit of Min (and everyone else) is worth fighting for. It’s worth fighting for your truth, for what’s right, it’s worth to be dumb and straightforward and to hear your heart. If made up rules don’t fit who you are, jump over them. Your life’s always ahead and being yourself is a risk you should always take.

one of the first queer visual novels i played ever. also about the first sport i was actually into. humor hasn't aged well but in like an endearing way. will always be a part of me. i do not consider myself sapphic in any way but i am nebulously queer and a poc so this game was some kind of awakening for me (even if that awakening was just "holy shit?? i can be gay??")

i have a lot of thoughts and memories surrounding this game i fear could only be accurately summarized through a full length blog review or 3 hour long video essay but. i will always be in love with these girls and their stories

Perhaps most notable for its cast, who are so goddamn extra I couldn't help but be endeared to them, even as the humor threatened to swerve into 'wow, so quirky!' That being said, the story they inhabit is woefully disjointed, bouncing between buffooneries and serious subject matter which isn't meaningfully addressed. The resolution of the story is sweet and delightful but left major subplots unaddressed. Even as I yearn for a more balanced narrative featuring these characters, I can still celebrate this game as a product of an independent creator's vision, discussing marginalized intersectional identities. Absolutely still worth checking out.

Butterfly Soup é charmoso, mas podia ser melhor. O jogo conta uma história de 4 garotas asiáticas queer na califórnia, em um time de baseball no seu 1° ano do ensino médio. A parte principal, que é a sua história, tenho sentimentos mistos. A narrativa aborda temas como racismo, abuso infantil e homofobia, mas com uma atitude otimista e carismática, e por mais que eu aprecie abordar tópicos sensíveis sem perder bom humor, não acho que esse jogo faz isso muito bem. A comédia, mesmo me fazendo rir algumas vezes, acaba sendo forçada com as suas tentativas de ser memética e suas referências à cultura pop. Quando resolve abordar tópicos sérios, acaba sendo mal desenvolvido e esses momentos são breves demais pra serem impactantes, além das subtramas envolvendo esses temas serem mal resolvidas. Mesmo com seus momentos de vergonha alheia, admito que as personagens divertem um pouco com as suas interações, mesmo que boa parte dos meus problemas com o humor venham delas. Outra coisa que incomodou, foi na trilha sonora. As músicas são de terceiros e os efeitos sonoros foram pegos de Ace Attorney, mas esse não é o meu problema. As músicas são muito baixas e os efeitos sonoros são inconsistentes, alguns sendo um pouco mais altos que a música e outros absurdamente altos. Mesmo com o seu roteiro fraco e tom inconsistente, ainda respeito Butterfly Soup pelo seu charme e suas boas intenções.

Prós: As personagens conseguem divertir; Os exageros conseguem ser ocasionalmente engraçados; As músicas até são boas (mesmo não sendo originais do jogo); Aprecio que tenham focado numa comunidade asiático americana (apesar de não aprofundarem tanto); Tem opção pra idioma português.
Contras: Os diálogos conseguem ser dignos de vergonha alheia; Força a barra com memes e referências de Cultura Pop; Subtramas e tópicos abordados mal desenvolvidos; Volume mal regulado na trilha sonora.