Reviews from

in the past


I haven't played Return of the Obra Dinn so I can't compare it to that but if it's as good as this I am interested. Solving murder mysteries and discovering the lengths people go for power was fun in this game. It was never too hard finding the answers though there were some that made me scratch my head a little. I love this art style and overall really enjoyed this game

People making incredible 4D chess moves in order to reach their goals and then dying in the most comically anticlimatic ways and chronic backstabbing disorder: the game

first part of my no commentary playthrough
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oZno1WJCS_0

Good but it got lost behind other games I wanted to play more at the time, will come back to this one another day when I've got more time to get lost in the story.

Um ótimo jogo pra qualquer um que goste de investigação.

Aqui, você será jogado em uma cena e deve coletar pistas e desvendar os ocorridos que precederam aquela situação.

A narrativa geral de Golden Idol é dividida em pequenas fases que no final se completam.

Pode não ser um jogo para todos, mas é ótimo tanto para quem gosta de jogos para pensar, tanto para quem quer jogar algo fora da sua zona de conforto

The perfect game to whet my appetite for more Obra Dinn-style mystery solving and logical deduction, complete with explorable snapshots in time to investigate and mentally reconstruct each grisly sequence of events from. Really enjoyed all the different twists and turns the story took.


One of the few games that actually satisfy my hunger for deduction based gameplay!! Finished it in a day bcs I couldn't stop playing!! Amazing visuals and surprising plot

Man, Count Rugen would've LOVED this thing

Las mecánicas son únicas y el arte del juego es increíble. No es una obra maestra pero se lo recomendaría a cualquier persona a la que le gusten los videojuegos.

Você vira um "detetive" de uma história bem doida. Jogo bem desafiador, história até certo ponto bem intrigante. Recomendo.

some of the best faces in games

Great detective game, hoping sequel will be as great as this game (sadly DLCs kinda disappointed me with their difficulty where second cases was the hardest for me and made me thinking for a long time)

The DLC is still kicking my ass, but by the time I rolled credit on the main game, it got me feeling proud of myself and kept making me think about its world.

Complexity of puzzles became overwhelming in the last few cases. The interface isn’t well adapted to the Switch either.

This game lived in my head rent-free after i just started chapter 11 so I accidentally solved the entire case at 2 am and physically sat up going ''OH SHIT'' when i Realized. Game good

Loved it so much I finished it in two days.
Clearly influenced by Obra Dinn, but with its own character. Visuals are surprisingly charming and the ost is very nice. The story is legit great spanning many years. Each case is fantastic, some more complex than others, but all equally entertaining. If you like detective games this is one of the goats.

PSA: The Switch version has a bug where the game resets your progress when you exit it! It doesn't happen to everyone, but it did happen to me. Ridiculous that it's still unpatched.

This is a solid first game from Color Gray Games. Even though I found some similarity to Return of the Obra Dinn, the gameplay still felt fresh, and I liked how the worldbuilding was interweaved with the solving mechanic. I am looking forward for more game from their company in the future!

(full review https://doorplays.substack.com/p/door-reviews-the-case-of-the-golden)

One of the better games in the detective genre and is worth playing if you liked 'Return of the Obra Dinn'.
The game gets extremally difficult at times but I suppose that's the type of thing you would want with this type of experience.

my favourite underrated game

An awesome detective game that knows how to craft satisfying murder mysteries out of paying close attention to the details of a crime scene. It also gets bonus points for using said crime scenes to tell its wider story.

Basically fine. Enjoyed a majority of my time with it and really enjoyed a few of the scenarios but I would often reach a point where I had ALMOST everything filled out, and knew the gist of what occurred, but there was one little ancillary mystery that I didn't have all the details of pinned down, so I couldn't finish the level. And at that point I'd already looked at everything and really didn't want to go over it all again with a fine-toothed comb to pick out the one or two extra little details that I'm Just Not Seeing that would let me finish.

So what often happened is I'd get like 85-90% of the way through finishing a level and decide "alright, I've spent enough of my life looking at this" and look up the final thing or two.

Basically, I was often sick of what the game was asking me to do before it was done asking me to do it. There was one party scene and one of the paragraphs you have to fill out was like "blank and blank went to blank to blank and ran into blank and blank before going to blank and seeing blank" and I was pretty sure that could describe about four things that happened and I didn't even try to fill it out, I just looked it up.

And the last scenario where you have to put the events in order? It was not interesting to me to figure out which of these largely independent events occurred at 7:30 and which occurred at 7:35. It doesn't matter, and I'm not going to sit here for an extra fifteen minutes trying to figure it out. I'll just guess.

they pay off everything that they set up in the dumbest and best way possible

Wonderful little deductive reasoning puzzler. Starts simple with basic "who killed who with what" but unfolds with increasing complexity as the game goes. By the halfway point I entered each scene thinking "this one might finally be too much for me", but always surmounted the obstacles in the end. That's the sign of a great puzzle game—one that always makes you feel like it's going just beyond your reach and then making you feel incredibly accomplished when you beat it.

Beautiful, oddball art and a compelling narrative tie these puzzles together as you trace the Golden Idol through multiple generations of warring factions.

With this and Obra-Dinn, I'm hoping this little genre booms in the indie scene immediately.

I love these sorts of slow-burning, player-paced, who-done-it-or-what mystery games, and this one was no exception. The Case of the Golden Idol progresses players through a series of scenes depicting a series of events in its game-world and asks the player "what happened here?". Then you collect clues in the form of fill-in-the-blank words and names, and lay it all out. Fairly simple in gameplay, but very satisfying in narrative presentation.

great game with original mechanics and clever gamedesign. the dlc are the best pannels by far. some of the music are really great too.

o final é bem cansativo, mas em geral é um obra dinn like bem gostosinho


Excellent mystery solving game. A bit futzy at times but worth it

A wonderful, intriguing game that glued me to the screen. If you like games like Obra Dinn and/or even remotely enjoy solving mysteries, this is an absolute blast to play. The DLCs are great, too.

I got stuck before too long and didn't feel drawn to come back.

really good, but fucking difficult lmao!! as an obra dinn devotee i will eat up this type of puzzle though!