Xenosaga Episode I is still one of my favorite games. There are so many things I love about it, and it surely has many problems, but I think the strengths of it easily outweigh the weaknesses of the game.
Probably one of the main problems of the game is that there isn't any music in most of the areas, and while I think in some cases, like the Dock Colony, it fits the atmosphere of outer space and the game very well, in others it's a bit distracting, and I don't really understand why in places like the Kukai Foundation there isn't any music. But I don't think it's that bad in the end, and all these other aspects of the game, which I absolutely love, I can definitely live with that. And I think it's better than in Episode II, where you have music in all the areas, but it's totally distracting because it doesn't really fit for Xenosaga imo, and that music is the complete opposite of the Kajiura tracks from the cutscenes and also doesn't really fit with those.
The characters are still my favorite fictional characters, and I absolutely love the story. While we haven't gotten a full and complete story with this game alone, I think what we've gotten with this game is still fantastic on its own.
Especially seeing all the foreshadowing and little details if you have already completely experienced the whole story of Xenosaga, it just becomes even better.
One thing that I also totally love in this game are the character interactions. Seeing all these characters, which I love, interact in all those cutscenes is always wonderful. So yeah, I absolutely love Xenosaga Episode I. This game still really means a lot to me, and I hope that someday it'll be released on modern platforms.

One of my favorite games and the series that introduced my favorite game character KOS-MOS. This is the best game in the trilogy no contest.

The story although very vague but maintains your interest. I gives you more questions than answers. But it's also the first game in a trilogy. The character are all great except Momo. A child character that is just annoying at every moment she exists.

The combat is simple yet satisfying. Learning weaknesses and planning the right moment to defeat an enemy to earn extra exp.

However the game is not perfect. There are too many types of points to spend and menus can be overwhelming. If you don't plan out how to spend your points you miss out on some good late game stuff.

One other issue is that it loves to waste your time. A lot of back and forth. Too long of cutscenes that do nothing to move the story at all. Long periods without combat.

The other major issue is it's lack of music. The game relies a lot on ambient sounds. When there is music, it slaps doe. Esp the final boss music.

It also has stupid difficulty curves and some annoying gimmick bosses.

But all in all, a fantastic JRPG with a great art style, story, world and characters. I fully recommend people to play it. The only problem is that the other 2 games in the trilolgy I cannot really recommend. So you won't get a conclusion unless you are will to suffer greatly.

Asura's wrath can be described as a very shallow experience when it comes down to it. But despite that this game has so much charm and style to it that it more than makes up for any big issues that come from the style of game it is. Probably like 60-70% of this game are qte cutscenes that will present you with some of the sickest shit you've ever seen in your life. Meanwhile that 30-40% is a mixture of a 3D fighter and a on rails shooter. Don't ask me how it all works cause it just kinda does. The story and characters have all the subtlety of an atom bomb but I think the over the top nature of it all works and it sucks that the true ending of the game is locked behind dlc that can be hard to experience nowadays cause I think those last 4 episodes have easily the best story and character moments in the whole game. This game is in desperate need of a definitive edition so the dlc can be preserved in a better way cause I emulated this game and getting the dlc to work that was a process in a half but seeing how we've seen hide nor hair of this game since it's release i have my doubts. Regardless the game itself was very sick experience that I'm glad i got to experience.