Positives
Expands on the lore of previous games.
Negatives
Horrible story that I could not care less about, boring gameplay with little to no challenge, worst final boss I've ever fought.

Positives
Iconic characters, better mystery and murder scenes than the previous game.
Negatives
Can be painfully boring and annoying in some parts. Ending is confusing and drawn-out.

Positives
Great story progression and plotwists, memorable characters.
Negatives
Some parts are annoying.

Positives
Era-defining game, it set the mark for open world RPG's.
Excellent gameplay, world-building and storylines.
Vast content and quests, you could milk it for months and have more to go.
Old but gold.
Negatives
Traveling to new locations can be tedious, horses are virtually useless. Traversing dungeons in late game becomes annoying as their design is unintuitive.

Positives
Great plot and characters, ahead of its time in many aspects, nostalgic.
Negatives
Lacks content, Main storyline is too abrupt.