Graphics - 4/5 The graphics in this game is beautiful and awe provoking. The vegetations, character detailing, diverse landscapes etc really adds to the immersion. Though the optimization on PC is really poor even after nearly 1 year of patches.

Story - 3.5/5 The story is good, especially the "Left Behind" dlc, moderately emotional story, but lacks the depth in Joel's character, and overall complexity, even if we consider the 2013 release. It doesn't really feel like how the majority of the reviews said about this game as outstanding. Also its predictable to the very end with no choices for the player and also pretty small storywise. Like indie titles. Also Joel should have died at the end, that would have been wayy more emotional.

Mechanics - 2.5/5 This game suffers heavily from really poor gameplay mechanics, the gunplay is not really satisfying, the melee combat is repetitive and boring, but the worst part of this game is the stealth system, its utterly tiring, while considering that this game was meant to be stealth centered. Also I hated the immersion breaking due to the other characters bumping into the zombies and nothing happens for that. It should have been player controlled on how the other characters move when they are in stealth.

Overall - 3.5/5 Before I played this game I heard a lottt of people saying how this game is a masterpiece and truly one of the best games ever. But I disagree with that completely, this game even if we consider 2013 release have nothing new to offer, a predictable short story made into a 12 hour game which barely considers as a AAA title, lackluster gameplay and little to nothing environmental storytelling with pretty much non existent soundtrack, every aspect of this game shouts mediocre. Even the remake suffers from severe technical issues upon launch and still not fixed with no improvement on the gameplay. Not a memorable game.

NOTES - 1. They really marketed this game well, other game devs should learn from the marketing of this game and how it convinced nearly all of playstation gamers to view this as an outstanding piece of art.
2. This might have been the most overrated piece of game ever (for history books).
3. My theory for why this game is praised so heavily - It was a playstation only title when it launched and stayed that way for 10 years, the first surge of reviews might have been fake so it brought the attention of the most casual of gamers, and as most of them haven't really played a lot of games only made them appreciate this one wayy more.
4. It is kind of proven these days how the game awards are kind of fake, and this game being heavily awarded just proves the point even more.

Graphics - 5/5 The most impressive graphics in a video game in recent years, still considered as the go to choice for testing ray tracing fidelity. Detailed textures, great lighting, and skillfully crafted distinct areas that runs well enough on modern hardware.

Story - 5/5 Night city with all it's beauty from above and all it's ugliness when walking down the sad streets, tells u a story of a dystopia where people had to merge with machine to gain their usefulness. The story revolves around someone who gain more than he was aiming for and what costed him everything, in the city of no good ending. Watch the anime series to gain full understanding of this universe, it will be a really emotional journey then. Certainly deserves a very high place in interactive and environmental storytelling. Especially after Phantom Liberty this have become such an impressive turnaround for the hate it received back when it launched. Truly deserves a place in top 10 best games of all time.

Mechanics - 4.5/5 An awesome combat system with good progression and nice enough driving, & metro system, but it have it's problems too, like mediocre AI system as well as open world feels a little hollow at times, also there are no flying or boating in this game.

Overall - 5/5 Though it started rough, but they really pulled up a 'no man's sky' with this game, the increadible story and 2nd to none graphical fidelity, diverse and complex combat system make it a solid recommendation if someone wanna immerse themselves in night city.

Graphics - 5/5 After 5 years of it's release it is still the most detailed game out there, nothing else to say. (The games anti aliasing is problematic so use TAA fix mod)

Mechanics - 5/5 This game is supposed to be the most realistic game ever made, and it shows how they achieved it, The physics engine, ragdolls, combat system, seamless animation, all of those tiny little details that 99% of people won't notice they did them all, it shows that how much effort they have put in this. From fishing, hunting, fully coded board games, Arthur's diary, the environmental effects on every creature, the cinematic camera, 35 mins plus full theatre shows, all of them and more, is designed perfectly.

Story - 5/5 What rdr2 presents us is a journey through the wild west as modern civilization expands. A gang on the run, trying to hold onto their ideals which breaks down eventually as they try to find their place in this new world, but slowly we realise it wasn't meant to be a story to find home, it's rather an end of an era. This is truly an interactive art, it provokes deep thoughts, and made us go through all of the emotions with its beautiful and varied soundtrack. It's not just a linear story it's an experience of a decade. All the side missions learning about the characters and their lives and impacting on them by what we do is a beautiful touch to one of the best protagonist ever created on a video game. It is just perfect.

Overall - 5/5 Rdr2 was a prequel to rdr1 released back in 2011, and it completes the previously untold, amazing story of van der linde's gang, games like this comes around only once a decade, and awes us in wonder of how even they achieve this masterpieces. Thanks Rockstar Games, you have made another giant.

Arthur Morgan -"You don’t get to live a bad life and have good things happen to you."
Dutch - "I've a plan!"

Story - 4.5/5 The story is well written and funny to say the least, it's like a bond movie but with a female protagonist and a long campaign, the levels are very well designed and bosses were awesome to fight against. Also soundtrack is awesome.

Mechanics - 4.5/5 Fast paced combat, stealth both are fun. The enemy AI is good enough.

Graphics - 4.5/5 It is good enough for when it released.

Overall - 4.5/5 Really great game, balanced, feels like an adventure even though it's fast paced and humourous.

Overall - 1.5/5 This game is just not for me, but as I played resident evil 6 before this and expected this to be as good and hearing everyone's appraisal towards this game, I thought of trying, and then realised that how dumb I was to not first see the gameplay, I expected this game to be stealthy, story rich and good enough combat wise, what I got was horror(which doesn't work at all), collecting stuff all game without any substantial story progression, puzzles that require u to go through the same path atleast 20 times before u can solve it, and 'NO' combat.

Graphics - 5/5 The only good thing about this game, it nails on the graphics intensity and it runs so well on lower end PCs.

Story - 1/5 It feels like story progress is just too slow, it doesn't justify the grinding at all.

Mechanics - 0.5/5 Feels exactly like a chore, and possibly one of the worst at that, combat is unrealistic and feels boring and repetitive, u can only walk at 10 cm/second and no other function, just move around solve cheap puzzles and move on to do another one, the worst thing is the inventory system, it's so unrealistic that it feels like playing some old arcade game minus the fun those used to bring.

Overall - 5/5 I would say that this is the best GTA game I've ever played, even though I played GTA 4 & 5, and yes they are awesome as well, but this one is just the definition of "PERFECT".

Story - 5/5 A journey presented by rockstar games as always, imo better story than gta 4 & 5, it is balanced so well, it gives u a feel of completion, adventure and nostalgia with the patented gta humour.

Graphics - 4.5/5 It is diverse, design wise unique and feels balanced, but the character graphics quality is a bit rough, games released on the same era had somewhat better graphics in some instances, but small details wise GTASA defeats them all.

Mechanics - 4.5/5 It does everything quite well, some things are a little hard to get used to, but the combat, driving, boating, flying all of them are enjoyable, the open world feels realistic and living, police chases are great as well.

CJ - "Ah shit! Here we go again..."

Graphics - 4.5/5 Needless to say NFS is one of the most graphically good looking game series, and so was this one, the beautiful environmental effects, good quality textures and detailed car designs were noteworthy as well as the open world, the only place it lacked a bit was vegetation quality and reflection, it ran with 30 fps on my ancient HCL laptop, pretty good I'd say.

Mechanics - 4.5/5 Car physics were really awesome in this game, its hard when u first start, but as u learn how to use nitro and breaks at proper time it gets really fun, the game AI is great as well, police chases were enjoyable and adrenaline inducing.

Story - 3/5 It's not meant to be a story based game, but it does have a guessable, simple storyline to put some purpose into it. Also the music is really great.

Overall - 4.5/5 First proper PC racing game played, not a big fan of racing games nowadays , but when I played it back in 2015 I was totally addicted on it, completing the challenges, getting bounties and escaping with my heavily modded car, even just roaming around on the highway as the sun sets, it was beautiful to say the least.

Graphics - 5/5 It blew me away on how good it looked on my retro laptop, the vegetation were dense and had quite realistic textures, underwater vegetation and graphics were awesome as well as the water physics, it was a treat to fly with the glider and to roam around.

Story - 3/5 The storyline was simple, but I liked how they put a lot of effort on environmental storytelling, and as the first game in its series it really holds up well storywise comparing to the later titles.

Game mechanics - 4/5 Stealth, normal combat both were good, driving and boating were fun especially the glider, gunplay good enough and so was the game physics and enemy AI.

Overall - 4/5 This game was a brilliant game when it released and especially cause I played this on my 2nd hand HCL laptop which had only 1 gb ram and very old ATI graphics also this was the first FPS game I played on windows platform, so it kinda holds some nostalgic value for me. Though I played it on 2015 I enjoyed every moment of it.