JRPG masterpiece, there is nothing else like this one. Improves on nearly everything from the prior games

Peak

It's Minecraft

One of the best open-world experiences I have had yet. Samey bosses and underwhelming shrines/beasts bring this one down

Actual peak fiction. World larger than imaginable, fantastic enemy variety, locations, graphics, playstyles... Favorite FromSoft so far

A wonderful send off to the cast with the connections the base game was missing to previous games

Fantastic DLC, absolute blast to play through

A mature game that falls short in its ending. Fantastic if it was separate from all the other games, but the suggestion that this includes stories and connections from 1+2 raises expectations higher than it meets

Some of the best music the series has to offer, and great characters that are brought down a notch by Eastern tropes. Length, combat, and graphics hold this game back

A fantastic introduction to one of Nintendo's best series, with some of the best music of any series. Suffers from its length and difficulty scaling