Maybe it's because I played The Devil in Me before this one and that one being so horrendous in all aspects that think I genuinely enjoyed this one quite a lot. Loved the overall presentation and personally didn't feel like it was trying to be Until Dawn 2.0.
Characters were a vast improvement over UD too, I found myself liking most of them by the end of the game. Gameplay itself did feel a bit more lacking than usual but I don't really play these games for mind-blowing gameplay either.
My biggest complaint is the ending, as it does feel very sudden and rushed. I also have to mention the motion capture does look very off every now and then, especially the facial expressions of characters looking exaggerated during dialogue.