Not nearly as good as Assault on Dragon Keep, and just like the normal game from Borderlands 3, it's carried by the gameplay.

The Good: Melee combat is really good and fun, the spells are a worthy replacement for grenades, and I think they are 100% better, weapon variation is as good as ever, the gunplay is flawless, the easter eggs are awesome, they are usually the best missions in the game, Mr. Torgue being in this game is also perfect, I enjoyed the Overworld and these incopetent writers from Gearbox were finally able to create a good villain.

The Bad: I didn't like the enviroments, they feel too overdesigned, which is a recurring problem with this game, the classes are really boring and having 1 skill tree each is annoying and doesn't encourage variation, the story is pretty bland and boring, almost all new characters are annoying and cringe.

The Ugly: The entire UI is dreadful, HORRIBLE to look at because it's too OVERDESIGNED, too many details that just hinders comparing gear and using the minimap for example. The endgame is also a joke, chaos chambers are boring as hell, and that is the only good farming spot, just awful.

One of the best remakes I've ever played, even though it stayed true to the original, there were a plethora of QoL changes that make this the best version of the game. There are a few problems, but the good parts REALLY overshadow them.

Some of the problems are: Tartarus still sucks ass, this type of dungeon is terrible, but the gameplay alone makes it bearable, the school Social Links being tied to school days, specially your party members, is awfull, the club is incomplete, it's REALLY ugly and they completely BUTCHERED Burn My Dread -Last Battle-.

The best thing they've done for this game, and they need to do this as well for P6, completely voiced Social Links. This makes the bad ones more fun and the good ones even better, even most dialogues across the game are voiced, this was awesome.

100% the most overhyped game I've ever played, nothing actually met my expectations, the story and the ost were close, but the way people talk about this game I expected A LOT more.

I'm quite impressed by how much stuff this game has to offer for a ps1 game, I completely understand how this game was revolutionary, but I still wasn't able to enjoy the game.

The story until the halfway point (end of Disc 1) was extremely mediocre, but thankfully it gets really good after, the OST as well. The animations, cutscenes and VFXs were the best part of this game, how they were able to do them in ps1 game is beyond me.

Now, the game has aged like milk, the menus maybe were good at the time but are awful to go through, the combat system that punishes you for not playing fast is annoying as hell, the Gold Saucer is the worst part of any game I've have ever played, every mini game is terrible to play, specially the snowboard, the random encounters are way too frequent and the characters are extremely hit or miss, none are really special. Also, this is a nitpick on the PS4 version, but the HD 3D character look really bad and out of place on the overworld, the original is way pretier.

Overall, the game gets carried by the story and the ost for me, I'm completely disappointed.

An awesome and worthy sequel! They managed to make the game feel different enough to the last 2 without changing much, and the game is also not long enough to feel repetitive, really liked the amount of time to 100% the game.

The story is just a bit better than the first game, the side activities are a sidegrade in my opinion, some are better, some are worse than before, the gadgets in this game is are ok, I prefer the old ones and the new abilities are really cool, just wish their cooldown was a lot lower or that they recharged between combat encounters. I also expected to be more original suits, but the new recolors of the repeting ones does wonders to most of them, and unfortunately, most of the new original suits are really ugly, with a few excepctions.

What was a lot worse for me were the crimes, holy fuck they are even worse than the ones in the first game, specially the car chases, they are completely automatic now. And the last big negative are the face models, I don't know what they did but it sure does look worse than SM Remastered and MM, but the worse offender is definitely Mary Jane, wtf happened to her face, at least they made her playable missions more bearable.

Overall, it's a sequel that actually is better than the first game, but not by a lot, just slightly better!