This is probably the most consistently fun mario game imo excluding its sequel. Unlike 64 and Sunshine, there’s nothing outright annoying or anything that I think the game would be better off without, yet I don’t think I would say I prefer this to Sunshine or Odyssey and only narrowly edging out 64 for me. It’s an amazing game, don’t get me wrong, it was the first video game I ever played even and I can’t even count how many times I’ve replayed it so it could just be that I’m so used to everything at this point that it doesn’t really feel as special to me anymore lol.

Switch version is very good and probably now the best way to play Pikmin 1 due to the crushing glitch seemingly being fixed finally. Unrelated to the version specifically, Pikmin 1 is still really fun even after finishing the sequels that I consider to be better than it and I’m glad the series is finally getting the spotlight it’s deserved for so long.

P.S for first time players: be absolutely sure to destroy the egg in the Distant Spring before it disappears after Day 15, there’s a nice reward that should make your playthrough a whole lot nicer

Talked to someone at work the other day who didn’t know what this game is, what is happening to our youth

should’ve had flo and zach

haters just don’t get it

idk guys I thought it was ok

WAHOO!!!!!!!!!!!

liked it a lot more this time than I did on my last playthrough but tiny huge island is still godawful and I probably still prefer most of the other 3d Marios lol

I think my standards were always gonna be too high since this game was the whole reason I wanted to play the series but sadly didn’t really enjoy this as much yakuza 2-5, 0, or judgment. Still good though, Ichi is a wonderful protag and the gameplay loop is fun enough for what it is. I think if LAD 8 irons out the pacing issues as well as a couple of other things then it has the potential to be the best in the series. Good base for the series going forward even if I’m not as big on it as I wanted to be.

This score is not really meant to reflect the psp version per se as I didn’t play sebec route in this and I consider it basically on par with the original in being just ok. Snow Queen Quest itself was just not very enjoyable imo as it basically felt like all the boring and tediousness of the gameplay was kept and I think the actual plot is less memorable too. Really feels like a kinda neat thing I suppose to maybe experience once and never again.

Pretty neat game even if the localization is laughably bad. A very average game in hindsight and I don’t think I’ll be thinking about it much in the future but there’s a couple of cool moments and getting to see how this series started is pretty nice.

it’s so peak bros

don’t play on brutal unless ur crazy like me

A Fantasy so Final that they made 15 more games about it

Somewhat entertaining for what it is and the fanservice and references present are really cool but they’re sadly not enough to save the gameplay from either being insanely tedious or boring as fuck at times

Edit: DO NOT go for the plat. Pretty sure I hate this game now

there’s no way lost judgment can somehow be better