KarrotaKun
2007
Shogun 2 is already a five star game, with Fall of the Samurai, I'd give it six stars it possible. Fantastic gameplay and politics. We finally got a TW game with firearms that actually functions. If we ever get Empire 2, I want it set around this era and to play just like this. Give me the American Civil War, CA!
2009
2011
2015
The combat is even better than 7's but sadly I feel that the narrative took a massive step down. I like Kiryu's half for the most part, but Ichi's feels incomplete and inconsistent. Several plot points and characters feel inconclusive. Also charging me 20 bucks for NG+ is asinine and I almost considered docking a star on that alone. Cut that shit out, Sega.
2017
2016
2012
Yakuza 5 has the audacity to have a narrative this bogged down with pacing issues and lame reveals only to simultaneously have the rawest gameplay of the series. FML I wish I could rate narrative and gameplay separately on here because, boy, the story for this game drags hard at points. But the gameplay is peak. Like, it's incredible. It's the best the series has ever felt to play and I recommend it on that alone. Plus it's got one of the best Kiryu designs.
2010
I'm not kidding when I say that the rubber bullets reveal soured my entire experience with this game. Saejima had so much potential as a character dealing with the guilt of taking people's lives and they completely pussied out on it. Sadly it doesn't get much better for him in the next game. Kiryu is also wildly out of character here. Tanimura is alright, shame about his VA and face though. Akiyama is awesome though. If there's any saving grace to this game, it's him. Combat is alright, I like the variety but it's still missing something.
2009
I've learned to get good and love this game, faults and all. Contrary to the common take, I love everything involving the orphanage. It just warms the soul seeing Kiryu do what he was always meant to. I only wish that the game was entirely about Okinawa and dealing with it's Yakuza instead of having the Tojo get involved. Also for the love of god play the remastered version. The OG NA release has not only one of the worst box art covers I've ever seen, but it's also missing 20 sub stories and a couple mini-games.
2006