NillyTheDog
1998
this is THE best 3D sonic game. love every part of it, every flaw and criticism of this game just adds fully into the charm with me, its a game that draws me in a lot and i often find myself just casually playing through, just to see whats up. i also got into sega bass fishing cause of this game, and it fucking rules. big the cat's gameplay rules. love that shit.
2017
2011
still a fun game! but i think it pales in comparison to sonic adventure 1. i feel like a lot of this game is weaker and lacks a significant charm that SA1 has over SA2. i still love both of these games, and SA2:B has the most fleshed out chao garden, but if you want a good sonic game i would hesitate to recommend sonic adventure 2