Reviews from

in the past


Free play-ið í Hogwarts er very cool, en uhhhh.
uuuuhhhhh

the spell system and open world is pretty fun but the story is lacking

After the mess that was the Goblet of Fire, EA went back to the drawing board and went in a different direction for the game based on the fifth Harry Potter movie. This time around, the focus would be on creating a fully explorable and movie-accurate Hogwarts.

This is the first Harry Potter game that attempts to give you the feeling that you're living through the world of the movie. Gone are the Zelda-inspired dungeons of the early Harry Potter games or the trashy co-op collect-a-thon levels in the fourth. This time around the focus is on walking around the massive castle, talking to students, and completing simple tasks.

As a big Harry Potter fan, I appreciate the attention to detail that went into this one. They went and scanned in the faces of the actors across the series, even down to the bit characters you wouldn't think of. It's little things like when you're running a quest from Colin Creevey (who isn't even in the movie but they brought the actor back anyway), or noticing little details in the castle that are accurate to the movie, where I was pretty impressed.

Unfortunately, it appears all of the focus when into creating the environment and the team forgot to include fun things to actually do in Hogwarts. Pretty quickly in Order of the Phoenix, you get a laundry list of tasks to tackle at your own pace. These are spread all throughout the castle, and often the quest itself will entail running a simple fetch quest from one side to the other. The game as footprints appear in the direction you're meant to go when you choose a quest on the Marauder's Map, but it still feels like most of this game is just running from one side of the castle to the other.

Some of the tasks do prove more interesting, but too much of them feel like filler. Other than working your way through the list, there are a few subpar minigames that Harry can play including Exploding Snap and Gobstones. Gobstones especially has really rough mechanics.

Throughout the castle there are chores to complete with your wand. There was actually some satisfaction to be had in fixing things up, which is intuitive as moving the right stick around in a certain way to cast a spell. The spell-casting system works well in these low stakes environments but when it comes to actual dueling it's a complete mess of spamming with a total lack of strategy. Dueling comes up very little in the game, only at specific story moments, which sounds disappointing but it ultimately works in the game's favor because the system is so broken.

There is no Quidditch or classes in the game and it can't help but feel that the whole experience is lacking some gameplay variety. While the Hogwarts setting is definitely impressive and I'll take it over the ugly series of levels from Goblet of Fire, but this game never quite realizes its full potential. Even so, it's probably the best of the later Harry Potter games and fans will probably get just enough out of it to make the experience worth their time.

always enjoyed these games becasue they covered plots from the books that were left out of the movies

The first open-world Hogwarts, eat your damn heart out Legacy! And it actually feels like the movie it was based on! And it even had motion controls for casting spells to boot!

Unfortunately the controls, and particularly the minigame design, do suffer a lot from the limitations of the Wii, and it does start to feel like too much like a collectathon at times. Also, if the movie feels like a watered-down version of the book, the game is kind of in-between the two, with some plot-points from the book that wasn't in the film, but then missing key parts of the movie.

Anyway JK Rowling is a terf and can get fucked. And so can Gobstones and Wizard Chess as well, they're the only reason I didn't master this one.


the gimmick is u can walk around Hogwarts which is guess isn't very different from Hogwarts legacy did

Se o Hogwarts Legacy caminha hoje, é graças ao caminho que esse jogo proporcionou. Mesmo sendo limitado, o fato de poder explorar mais Hogwarts, torna esse jogo muito mais interessante que os anteriores. Além disso, aqui você finalmente como a ter duelos mais interessantes e novas opções de magias.

cool hogwarts, shitty spellcasting

A return to form with an open world Hogwarts, but still a step down by introducing strange analog stick controls to conjure spells. A fun and challenging game, sadly plagued by what was popular at the time- motion controls.

A fantastic game representation of the book. I loved exploring the hogwarts and it was so great to finish some side quests with magic

SE LES OLVIDÓ LA DIVERSIÓN

Tras un mediocre pero entretenido (si jugabas con amigos) Harry Potter y El Cáliz de Fuego que se convirtió en un juego random de acción estilo Señor de los Anillos, llega La Orden del Fénix con la premisa de volvernos a dejar explorar Hogwarts, sin embargo, tenemos un grave problema.

Si recordamos, los 3 primeros juegos de Harry eran aventuras que, si bien no encajaban dentro de los libros o películas, estaban hechas para que el juego fuese divertido. La adición de criaturas mágicas como enemigos, el hecho de que las clases fuesen circuitos de obstáculos o los petardos mágicos.

Pues aquí nos olvidamos de todo eso, todo eso está calcado de la película, lo que significa que solo vamos a estar dando vueltas de un sitio a otro charlando con gente y haciendo alguna estúpida tarea secundaria hecha para conseguir atravesar los retratos o tener buena puntuación en clase ¿Quieres usar magia para luchar? Solo tienes duelos contra estudiantes y los obligatorios de la historia, fin.

Otra cosa ¿A quién se le ocurrió de que ahora los hechizos se hiciesen con movimientos random de joystick? Lo entiendo para la versión de Wii, pero ¿El resto de versiones? ¿Por qué?

Best version of hogwarts before Legacy

ПЕРВАЯ ИГРА В ОТКРЫТОМ МИРЕ ЧЁ???

the graphics felt almost photorealistic for the time and hogwarts has never looked more beautiful, but they really picked the weakest movie in the series to go off wth

fantastic depiction of hogwarts, making it feel like a properly realised space compared to the more gamey orientations of the previous entries. the spells being set to particular waggles of the analog stick is interesting but misreads intent too often. side quests fun, main questline boring, but that's because it's the order of the phoenix. alpha-hogwarts legacy

to this day i have not beaten the ravenclaw at chess nor the slytherin at gobstones

This review contains spoilers

This game is better than the last 2. The Story is the same, apart it being more simplified to focus on gameplay, and the story is highly inferior because of that. The Voice acting is the best that it's been since chamber of secrets, they sound closer to the film's quality. The Graphics are not great for the PlayStation 2, the world look great, and models are good, outside of the facial features that bring it down a bit, but the design of the castle is the most impressive thing in the game, it looks exactly how it should look, minus the quidditch stadium which you can't get to. The Gameplay has you explore Hogwarts doing tasks to continue the story, casting spells using right analog stick controls, which is a great way of having spells done without going to the menu a lot. The Dialogue is skippable so careful what you press, you can do tasks to be allowed through portraits to get around the school faster, the room of rewards for flicking your wand on things shows behind the scenes clips and stuff, the least interesting thing in the game to get. Despite the Castle's size, you can't do much around it outside of missions and wizard card games, you can fight other people in the game by casting spells at them, which is fun, and for more tense moments, you can lose fights and continue, putting stuff on the line, but that doesn't make sense during the final fight, Voldemort should have killed Dumbledore if he won that fight. Going around Hogwarts collecting members for Dumbledore's army, they are varied and lets you know the different students more. There are 3 lessons you can do, but you only do each one once and that's it, and occlumency lessons are a bit fun, if a bit too easy. But House points are gone, even if you point you want at the teachers to lose points, it won't make a difference. Music is good and fit each scene though. Order of the Phoenix is a good game, that fails to be 2nd best due to the lack of stuff to do in Hogwarts despite how big and almost perfectly designed it was.

El 2do mejor juego de harry potter

Exploring Hogwarts is fun but it misses the the mark from the first two games.

First game that feels like the movie and was fun running into people because they drop all of their books.

Antes de Hogwarts legacy pensar em nascer, existia um jogo de HP que ambientava bem a escola e fez fama na era do PS2 e tenho certeza que muita gente jogou esse aqui e não terminou, assim como ocorreu comigo na época.

Ordem da fênix não é um jogo tão memorável, mas ele é divertido o suficiente pra te dar uma experiência sólida e completa, isso claro considerando que era um jogo de 2007

Seus gráficos são mais ou menos, tendo em conta que ele é da mesma época que Assassin's Creed 1 e God of War II, hoje ele já envelheceu mal e não agrada mais tanto os olhos, porém da pra engolir seco.

E sobre a sua gameplay em geral ela é ok, nada incrível e nada péssimo, na medida, o bom é que ela não envelheceu tão mal assim, e se você for curioso o suficiente da pra explorar alguns cantos de hogwarts assim como fazia no câmara secreta e isso sem dúvidas, me encantou nesse título.

Ele receberia 4 estrelas, porém darei 3 porque esse jogo é complicadissimo de rodar no PC atualmente e tem vários bugs e crashs que vão incomodar, mesmo se você decidir deixar ele... vanilla por assim dizer.

Probably the most immersive Harry Potter game on the ps2, aside from chamber of secrets. I spent a lot of time searching hogwarts for all the secrets, truthfully the secrets were probably my favorite part of the game, and I will never forget those cursed gargoyles or the portraits password quests. Combat was pretty wack though

Epic open world type Hogwarts with lots of unique collectibles.

Fun open world HP experience , some quest are a bit boring. Love how spells were introduced.

being able to explore hogwarts is really cool and all but it and i hate to say this but it gets old and boring real fast

Flipendo but now has teenager issues.

This game tried to do what Hoghwarts Legacy did years later... But without the grinding and the open map bs.


didnt have a memory card for my ps2 growing up so every time id play this itd be from the beginning n lots of memories were made. revisiting this game involved the quest of finding a copy that wasnt corrupted. luckily i was able to find one at my local cex store (over a year of waiting for an alternative to the £30 copy listed on amazon) and the gameplay was just as good as i had remembered it :))) nostalgia always wins. the side quests and collectible missions can be tedious but it means getting to discover all sections of the map.

meu jogo era em português de Portugal, acho que foi o jogo que melhor representou Hogwarts, era td mt bem feito

This is one of those games that was neat because "Ooh I shake the thingy and the thingy happens in the game too!" unless you played it on dear god anything but a Wii, in which case it's just weird. Anyway, not bad, it's okay I guess. The fully explorable Hogwarts is cool, and some of the segments are fine I guess, but that's about it