The controls are a bit janky, but the game truly feels like playing a Stephen King novel. The DLC aren't quite as strong, just played them for the completionist's sake.
The worst thing about nostalgia is that things usually aren't quite like we remember them. For Diablo 2, I didn't remember it as tedious, especially with inventory management. I never thought I'd say this but I do prefer Diablo 3 over 2.