Pros:
- Dungeon design is mostly fantastic and great puzzles
- Cool aesthetic and character designs
- Midna

Cons:
- Gameplay is rougher than other 3d zeldas. Many bugs & just generally needs more polish to be satisfying
- Feels like every segment except the dungeons is filler
- Story is thin and kinda nonsensical at points

It's zelda so it's obviously good. But this one has enough rough edges that I'm unsure why it's held in such high regard compared to other games in the series.