alear is somehow worse than corrin in every way, the dialog is insufferable, the cutscene animations vary between bad mocap and sfm porn in quality, and the majority of the cast is just as one note as the fates/awakening characters but with even less appealing designs. the only positives in this game are the map design and the in battle animations, which are both surprisingly good, but still far from the best the series has to offer and the emblem system makes the act of playing the game trivial. everything else is just a testament to the fact that fire emblem has been on a downward spiral since the release of awakening. the kusakihara directed games seem to be the only ones we can expect to do anything right in terms of characters and story, but even then based on the two games we've gotten they aren't that great aside from the one that is based on an existing game.
speaking of the existing games, it's also very frustrating to me how flanderized or just completely mishandled the emblems are. for a title that was initially an anniversary project you'd think they'd show a small amount of respect to the source material they're supposedly celebrating, but instead they decide to drag the legacy characters down to the level of the modern franchise in terms of writing and characterization to the point where the filler voice lines from the gacha game are better representations of these characters

i'm sure if you started with modern fire emblem and don't care for the older titles you'll enjoy this game but i absolutely hate it, and i would've preferred fire emblem to die with new mystery than become whatever the hell it is now. hopefully we'll eventually get a title that recaptures what the series used to be outside of remakes of what it used to be, but based on the trajectory of intelligent system's other rpg series, i sincerely doubt it.

addendum: i went back and finished the game, here is my review with my thoughts after not abandoning it halfway through

Reviewed on Jan 20, 2023


19 Comments


1 year ago

didnt know where to put this in but my most positive takeaway from my actual experience was a death scene that was supposed to be sad taking 7 minutes to do an exposition dump that was so poorly written and animated that i was crying from laughing

1 year ago

i have never in all my life seen such horrible character designs... who does this appeal to? i'm also glad someone else agrees that modern fe isnt all that great... i wish the series ended with path of radiance haha

1 year ago

honestly i'd agree with it ending with path of radiance if i didn't personally enjoy new mystery so much, i've been slogging through radiant dawn too and not having too great of a time with that one either

1 year ago

ohh radiant dawn is one of the worst games i've ever played, it ruins everything good about por so horribly- i have no idea how they dropped the ball so hard on that one. i think i could complain about it all day.. i actually got softlocked at the very end because my characters werent strong enough, somehow. i was only doing it for soren and ike's support anyways, but still...yeah, also i've also never heard of new mystery! is it good?

1 year ago

it's a remake of mystery of the emblem and the fire emblem satelleview side story that has really good map design and is one of the better implementations of a my unit, and the music is also really good

1 year ago

ohh how cool! i havent heard of that one, i'll definitely look into it tomorrow- thank you very much (: !

1 year ago

im going to kill fire emblem with my bare hands
I'm so glad we're already getting people malding in the reviews despite the game literally releasing today

1 year ago

^ this guy just found out that games leak online before they release
This comment was deleted

1 year ago

so true bestie!! new mystery for life

1 year ago

the series will be saved when we get Newer Mystery of the Emblem for the switch 2

1 year ago

"i wish the series ended with path of radiance" and miss out on radiant dawn? 😤

1 year ago

even if im not having fun with radiant dawn so far it's worth it to have it exist because of heather and meg

1 year ago

cheadle wouldn;t say this

1 year ago

based path of radiance fan

1 year ago

Radiant Dawn try some of the most interesting thing on this franchise (with FE4&5), respect the best FE game please.

" i actually got softlocked at the very end because my characters werent strong enough, somehow"
=> Probably your fault, not the game. Radiant Dawn isn't even difficult. I don't know how people keep saying that when every new FE games since then (except Echoes) have far higher difficultes.

1 year ago

completely blown away that it can get WORSE than fates

1 year ago

god this is so rea. i left out SO much of what i wanted to say in my review because this game is hid eee ous and doesnt deserve that much of my energy but its genuinely baffling they would do this to such beloved legacy chars. pipe dream dialogue from all of them that it makes heroes somehow feel less silly in retrospect. whole thing felt insulting to to me as a long term fan. no idea how they're supposed to be like "yo check out how cool roy, sigurd, and leif are!" with their soulless one line generic words esp when half this series is locked behind emulating them with fan translations! shakes your hand in new mystery and por enjoyer. big shame new mystery wasnt officially localised bc i think it would have been much more popular than it is.

1 year ago

Even as someone who's favorite Fe is awakening, I gave up on the game. Which is a problem for it bc the gameplay panders to awakening fans heavily, and yet I found myself not able to finish it because of how awful the story is. It isn't like fates or radiant dawn or three houses or blazing blade or sacred stones where I can see a version of those stories which are good or even great, it's like a truly worthless concept. It's so hollow and empty and it's the first fire emblem game to really feel like that. Even the worst fe games previously had that little spark of creativity and intrigue in them that makes me want to see them be reattempted. Because despite 3h and Rd and fates being poor games, I can think of not too different versions of them that are my favorites in the series. I genuinely can't imagine a version of engage that's better than the one we got. It sort of executes what it wants to do perfectly, but what it wants to do is embarrassing bad and creatively empty.