Probably the best of the remakes, the surface world is very fun and a good change from the "caves again" setting of the previous two. The hidden time limits are also interesting.

This one is quite good, and greater party member choice (lizard, kitty) does make the game interesting, but this is counterbalanced with the weird way the game is structured. It works though.

It's pretty good, I assume it's an improvement on the much older original. The setting too is fairly interesting.

It's good, but a bit slow thus far. I may someday finish it and have more of an opinion.

Better than the original, though it does struggle with many of the same issues, in particular the difficulty being erratic.

But Alcander is there to be a whiny deva so that makes it better.

A little clunky and it's very possible to put yourself into a position where the game isn't really winnable, even on lower difficulties. However, it is nonetheless a good game.

Easily the best of the original geneforge games, but you really should play them in order to get this one. The gameplay is solid also.

Probably the weakest of the geneforge games, this one has a lot of transitional things going on and struggles with a lot of its goals. It's fun, but a lot of it drags while other parts feel too fast.

A transitional fossil of a game, it's very fun, but awkward, coming at a weird moment in spiderweb design philosophy. The maps are also very restrictive compared to both earlier and later entries.

An improvement over the original, but has a bunch of minor bugs and major jank that can render large sections of the game a pain or completely trivial if you know how to exploit the extremely unbalanced mental magic spells. It is also showing its age, like the first.

Classic, obviously, but is really starting to show its age, following many older spiderweb game design choices that have since been abandoned. It's still playable of course, but the remake is better.

Flatly fairly good, and the narrative gets interesting if you look around a bunch.

It's extremely good, but many positions are much less interesting than others, though we hold hope that that could change. The game also suffers from a few bugs that disrupt gameplay.

Very solid, and the bugs tend to be minor. Nearly any ruler is fun to play, which is great.

Amazing, but lacks replay value beyond achievement runs