Required reading. Video Game Canon. The GOAT.

Complete and utter mess but the highs are so high. Can't really hate it

I recognize how good it is but just never could fully click with it.

I am in a constant state of awe that this game even exists

Minus half a star for being the reason Ice Climbers were cut from both this and the Wii U version

More like Jonathan SUCK amirite

But for real it's fine. Overrated. I can appreciate aspects of it but I think the game actually fails at it's oh-so-clever design goals, some ideas are horribly communicated to the player.

The soundtrack is so nostalgic. The game is so bad.

Another in the category of "not a perfect game, but a 10/10 game"

Legit just having 100 Naruto characters to goof around with is the main selling point

Soundtrack: 10/10
Game: 5/10

So it averages out. Still love everything about the aesthetic and think a successor could be truly special

Yeah I'm thinking it's a masterpiece

Still the only Halo I've finished. It's... not very good???