SweetJT
2020
Holy shit, it's a Souls game where you don't get half your health taken out by a single attack?! It's the shortest and easiest game in the series, but the look and worldbuilding are top-notch. It also probably has my favorite boss lineup in the series. Ironically, pretty refreshing after Dark Souls 3.
2018
2016
Man, these games are great but these days I can't help but get annoyed by them. Especially since Souls became the template for modern action games. Everything about the series comes together so well, the world is so interesting, the exploration and level design are top notch, and it lets you be so flexible in your approach that it's easy to want to go back to it. But then you die thanks to an overzealous input buffer, have to do ANOTHER run back to your souls, eventually get fed up fighting the same enemies over and over so you run past everything, fight a boss which will sometimes have a cool gimmick, and then get you invaded because you automatically opt-into online play after a boss. The highs hit really high, but it's probably not a coincidence that I finish one of these games felling exhausted thinking "yeah I think I'm done with this gameplay style for now".
2023
2015
2020
1998
2019
2021
I've probably played Sonic Adventure 2 once a year for over 15 years, but I just finished my first 180 emblem playthrough, and the emotional payoff of Sonic finally going home at what was supposed to be the ending of the series is unbeatable. Chao Garden being too bloated and a handful of bad missions aside, this is one of the best games in the entire series.