Loved it. Slick graphics and framerate, rewarding gameplay.

My favorite game as a 17 year old when it released. Perfected shooting gameplay.

Good game but some terrible levels (what is up with the Yoshi eating fruit mission and that boat shine?).

Way better pacing than the 2nd one, incredible atmosphere and all. Looked very good for its time.

Enjoyed it as a co-op romp, not so much in single player. Screw that witch and her scream!

Thought it was a thrilling experience the first time. As I played it again a few years later I thought it was a bit rubbish, but that's probably because I knew how everything was going to go.

For a Dark Souls it was a letdown, but it was still a pretty good game. Scholar of the First Sin was way worse than the original, though.

Playing in co-op: yes, please. Playing alone: get out of here, NOW!

great graphics, boring gameplay, average story.

solid if unspectacular. Good looking

lots of possibilities but lots of annoyances and not very fun overall

mediocre gameplay, some nice ideas regarding mythology, but overall too repetitive

liked it back when I was younger and basically started the Ubisoft formula. Didn't get as repetitive as it should have.

great atmosphere, clunky controls and gameplay.