The presentation and visuals are top-notch as to be expected from Naughty Dog, the gameplay is well-refined from the original, and the bleak, oppressive tone the game's going for with its ambitious story is respectable, though unfortunately its writing and storytelling crack under the weight leaving a sour taste in the mouths of both players looking for a safe and consistent sequel to the original and those looking for a more challenging, risky narrative that commits to complex themes at the expense of beloved characters.