guiltyparty
2000
1993
1991
2000
2020
2016
Charming character dialogue and occasionally satisfying cinematics do little to distract from this game's more egregious shortcomings, which are amplified by the sky-high expectations it set for itself over the course of its ten-year dev cycle. Ultimately a fair game, but as the credits roll on this "Final Fantasy for fans and first-timers," it leaves one wondering just what could have been.
Sporting a tidy narrative with a strong thematic core, Innocent Sin's punchy and personal character writing makes it a standout among its contemporaries. Unfortunately, the real meat and potatoes are hidden behind a sluggish battle system that requires minimal player engagement until the final boss hits. Push through the exasperating encounter rate and you'll find a story with a fair amount of bite, that isn't afraid to throw you into the deep end.
2018
The "rogue-lite" structure feels like a solid fit for Supergiant, a clean shift off the heels of Bastion and Transistor. It's a neat little game with a menagerie of kooky characters, and the gameplay loop is enjoyable enough that it'll usually squeeze one more run out of you, just when you think you're about to put it down.
Thanks to its slick traversal when you're slinging around Manhattan, Spider-Man feels best to play in short bursts to do in-game "busy work," whether it's finding a tower, nabbing a backpack, spotting black cats, or stopping a crime-in-progress. While the gameplay loop begins to show its seams in the back half of the main story, where encounters are at their most tedious, it's fine to play mindlessly.