Nice set-pieces. Awsome graphics. Finally a smooth gamplay/fighting in the whole game series.

But man... it's totally boring. I can't play it until the end.

I liked the most quests / presentation / dialogs of the whole game. And this is the only part of the game why I played it until the end.

But sorry the gameplay is (for a triple AAA product) crap.
150h+ and nothing changed. The fighting system don't works well. You got so many sword/gears and you can do nothing with it because the witcher gear is ALWAYS better.
Geralt runs like a tank... yes also in the alternative controls.

The technology is also crap (I played on PS4 pro) Framerate drops... crashes... (~20-30 in the whole game).. loading times from hell (90s+) (and not only at the first loading... on every fucking death or area changes)

I'm really sad about it because I wanted love the game the whole playtime and always I was angry about this points in every game session.

I love Part I. It is one of the best games of all times. I have to give Part I 5 Stars.

And then comes Part II. I thought there is now way to make it better. But for me, they have done it. If I could I would give 6 Stars.

I understand the problems of some peoples with the story. But for me and also for my wife (we played it together) it works perfect. We love revenge storys. And we are always on the side who say "An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth". So maybe this is the reason why we have no problem with any aspect of the game.

I pray to god that they can make part III. I want to see more of Ellie and Abby :-)

Chapeau! Naughty Dog for this masterpiece!

A cool, funny couch-coop game. But don't expect any challenge gameplay.

I really liked it, so I spend over 100h in this game since release. But every time i played it, I missed the "weight of the hits"... the hit feedback. It just feels kind of floppy.
Hopefully they make it better with the next game.

The mother of "walking sims", but not the best.

A really underrated game. The combat mechanics are functional. The presentation lacks budget. But the narrative is fantastic.

I don't understand all this hate about the game. Maybe it's the long thirst, because I've been waiting so long for a new Mass Effect, but for me the story and the characters worked really well. I was fully invested and was a little bit sad when it was over. Even though the next Mass Effect won't be Andomenda 2 because of the failure, I hope it will be continued in one way or another.

I see the repetitive gameplay, of course. But I could handle that. Personally, I had fun with it, too.

I can't remember the last time I was so caught up in a game. Perfect for me from start to finish. Game Mechanics / World Building / Story / Athomsphere.
A masterpiece.
I will never forget it.

At the beginning you think: "It's not that bad" "Awesome shooter feeling".
But after 30min you realize that's it, you have seen everything.
I don't understand why even the handful of main missions weren't worked out better...

Just what I needed. I love the main character (in interaction with his wife). I love how the mystical world of Egypt is portrayed. I love the wide world without being overwhelmed with pointless side quests. And I love the music :-)

I also loved the history tours that I watched at the end.

For me a step backwards from the previous one. Worse fighting feeling, too inflated world and above all the procedurally generated quests are annoying. Hopefully they will go back a bit the next part.
The DLC's are great though.

I really enjoyed it. But there was so much more potential in the game. Hopefully they can develop a second part with a little more budget, because I really believe it will be great.