Played the 3D remake.

Good
- 3D sprites is amazing.
- Soundtrack is amazing!
- Job system! Everyone gets to be whatever they want to be!

Meh
- Storyline. (However this fits the earlier years of JRPG games, heroes killing dark lord story)

Good
- Dungeon exploration.
- Storyline is surprisingly good.
- Battle mechanics.

Meh
- Questing.

Good
- Amazing soundtrack!
- Amazing character design and development (only made better with P5R)!
- Amazing battle system.
- Amazing dungeon design and boss design (chills when I first saw the first boss).
- Fusing demons is like Pokemon breeding on steroid.

Meh
- Gets a little draggy at the end on the game.

Good
- Endless battles in item world.
- Characters are still quite funny.
- Character and item customisation.

Meh
- Story line is forgettable.

Good
- The MMORPG-ish battles and gambit system is pretty interesting.
- Early storyline (very political).
- Dungeon design and battles.
- Soundtrack is good.

Meh
- Characters are pretty forgettable and some outright annoying.
- Later part of the story seems to escalate without proper development.

Good
- Pretty good turn based mechanics.
- Art style.
- Dungeon exploration.

Meh
- A little easy for my taste.
- Character customisation could be more in-depth.

Bad
- Performance and frame rate issue.

Good
- Storyline is amazing, with those 15-30mins cutscenes between chapters being the highlight!
- Japanese VO and character design/development is amazing.
- Gacha system for blades. (I do like some gacha elements to these games so long as it is not game-breaking)
- Exploration and questing.

Meh
- Battle gets a little draggy at the end but manageable.

Bad
- Performance on handheld is shit.

Good
- Battle mechanics! (a blend of real time and turn based tactic games is a really refreshing take on the genre)
- Art style and map design.
- Storyline is good.

Meh
- Slight stutter in performance.
- Moving around during active mode can be a bit choppy.

Good
- Quicker and more engaging battles.
- Storyline is good (prologue to XBC2 storyline).
- Character design and Japanese VO (English VO is really bad and cringy).
- Exploration and questing.
- Those 15-30mins cutscenes are really good!

Meh
- Removal of gacha system in acquiring blades.

Bad
- Perfomance on handheld is shit.

Good
- Battle, character customisation is amazing.
- School intermission is always a nice break from constant battles.
- Artwork is amazing (except from character sprite during battles)
- 3 main characters and 3 completely different storylines to play. Does create a very strong bond between players and house picked.

Meh
- Animations could have a little more variation.
- Character animation and design (becomes boring after a few battles in).
- Those random mob spawn in mid battle can be annoying.

Bad
- Fishing.
- Performance and character sprite (low-res).
- Romance option (where are the good LGBT ones).

Good
- QOL upgrade: battle speed & insta-win just to go through the story.
- Junction system is still fun.
- Triple Triad.
- Soundtrack is amazing.
- Story is whacky but pretty interesting.
- Upgraded sprites: didn't know everything looked so bad with the PS1 version.

Meh
- Squall and Rinoa's relationship.

Good
- Story is interesting enough at the start, gets a bit predictable at the end though (heroes kill demon lord).
- Characters! Interesting, fun with really good English VO.
- Town design and open area exploration.

Meh
- The art style isn't my thing, but it does grow on you.
- Battle can seem repetitive at times.
- Soundtrack is serviceable.
- Game is a little longer than it needs to be.

Good
- Deep character development.
- Extra stories and dungeons.
- Amazing battle system, dungeon design and boss battles.
- Amazing soundtrack!
- Amazing game pacing between school life and dungeon exploration.
- Better Mementos exploration.

Meh
- That new Phantom Thieves room.
- Storyline that is quite predictable, but execution with all the characters made it above average.