not even that bad !! But intentionally played before the legendary edition came out and having last played the good ones like at least 5 years ago so I wasn't directly comparing lol.

Played a 2nd time to see the added stuff, which was pretty good, like more of the same goodness as what was already there. It is a little weird playing the whole beginning when you already know how it ends, but it's still so Nice & the music does as the kids say "slap."

Well it was very shiny but somehow it was not as fun as doom 2016...

It is rly sad how it keeps encouraging u to play online and participate in the #community etc. : (

Some of the extra creation club stuff broke the game and made it crash all the time for a second, which was a pretty authentic 10th anniversary celebration of when I played it on PS3 tbh

The things that were a little annoying the first time were much more annoying the second time. The camouflaged loading screens are Quite conspicuous and irritating... similarly the mixing of gameplay with cutscenes like... I would rather just watch a cutscene than watch half a cutscene, push the stick for half a second, and watch the rest of it. Also the combat only gets good once you add some more abilities / weapons ... and the Valkyries are SO ANNOYING hard to the very edge of not being fun at all. Sigrun (on baby mode) took me more tries than any boss in any game I think

Anyway still very good and I am definitely glad I replayed this before starting the sequel as I had forgot some important stuff lol.

Definitely my least favourite of the 4 soulsbornes I have played .. I was constantly staggered and killed if I got hit 1 time like .. let me stand up and do something

Did u kno games can look like this now whoa man

It was impossible for the story/world to be as Compelling as the first one. But still p good

hot take this game is Too Big and has Too Much Stuff

(legendary edition PS5) so much stuff in not a stupid long amount of time. a classic

(Legendary Edition PS5)

Excellent until the ending which still Sucks Mega Hard

I never played the DLC back in the day so those were fun. I appreciated how unabashedly stupid the Citadel one was

I was expecting this to be more like the Wii version because it totally has all the stuff, being the ultimate edition u kno, and it did have Jedi Temple levels ... but they were completely different levels. wot. this game is so weird. I guess I have to acquire a Wii in 2022 if I want to relive my original experience.

This is still fun tho even tho it often like. Doesn't work lol

2022

Extremely aesthetically pleasing (tunes, robots, ~atmosphere~, cat)
The gameplay did get to be Mixed Review-worthy toward the end.
If this was Letterboxd I would rate it 4 stars + heart

(Legendary Edition PS5)
Because I played the second and third games a few times before I ever played this one back in the day (once it came out on PS3), the first one has always felt to me like an inferior prequel rather than u kno The One That Started It All. Still worth playing to go through the whole thing I think, but even with the improvements, it has been so long that I don't really remember what it's improving, and the "modern" graphics kind of just emphasize more that this game is like. from 2007

I miss the jumping from Andromeda tbh lol