I played it on PS4 when it first came out and loved the atmosphere on the giant TV. Years later, when my interest in the game's story and atmosphere grew again, I decided to play it all over again on PC, but this time I also wanted to finish all the DLCs. After finishing the main game, I moved on to the DLCs and today I finished the game after 109 hours. Honestly, I enjoyed every moment.

The atmosphere is strong, Greece is wonderful and spacious, the architecture is impressive and some of the characters are interesting and fascinating, the DLC zones are incredibly beautiful (Elysium, Underworld or Hades and Atlantis), the soundtrack is good, traveling by ship is nice and many other pleasant experiences.

As for the cons, I think the main story is a bit lackluster, it feels a bit disjointed with the side quest structure of the game. Even though the characters are strong, I got bored at some point with the story being so sprawling, but as I said, the positive things cover it up to some extent. Honestly, Greece is incredibly big and there's a lot to explore, but I didn't give up and kept going. Even though the mission structure felt repetitive, I kept seeing the positives. The combat system gets very repetitive as the game gets longer and longer, and after a while you can't find a gameplay style. The abilities are good, but as I said, the repetitiveness is a bit overwhelming. New abilities are unlocked with DLC, or existing abilities get stronger as you play the Atlantis DLC. This reduces repetition a little bit, but a lot of people may not have gotten to this point and seen these things, so this point is a little bit more for the people who are loyal to the game. Our character's animations aren't nimble, they're a bit heavy or clunky as they're a bit more RPG-ish, and frankly, I found myself missing the old-school nimble and different animations. As heavy as the character is in this game, I would have liked to see more, jumping, running, walking and similar animations.

I also enjoyed playing the Atlantis and Legacy of the First Blade DLCs, but again, the fact that they are too long is a shortcoming. There is no need for it to be so long. Ubisoft can't or doesn't want to adjust this... I'm satisfied with what I've seen here and what I've learned about how the other games continue. The information about how the story starts and how it will continue was very helpful. Both DLCs had their own unique, character-changing narrative touches, both happy and sad. Anyone who has played up to this point will obviously not have any question marks.

In summary, I enjoyed and digested this game in general. It is a game that can provide continuity by covering its shortcomings with other positive things. I did not and will not regret spending my time on this game, even though Ubisoft made it. :D Thank you to everyone who has read this far, I hope I've translated your feelings somewhere...

First of all, I think it's a pure experience, different from other games. There's less interaction, more story. There was a lot of discussion about it, but my opinion was that it's not like other games. It's a game and it probably doesn't fit your definition of a game, but it is. It's like What Remains of Edith Fitch, the presentation is like that. There's a story and we move through it with atmosphere. We walk and sometimes we fight. There's not a lot of interaction along the way, but we are affected by what we see.

Even though everything is good at this point, my expectations from this game were a bit different. The first game was graphically average, but this one looks much better. The fighting wasn't as intense and impressive in the first game, but I found it much more intense and impressive in this game. I also noticed that some things didn't change. The puzzles were average again, it's a pity that they didn't follow a different path. There were very few moments to interact in the cutscenes. For example, there could have been moments where you could press certain buttons while fighting, climbing, or defending. It could have been like Detroit: Become Human, but it wasn't. It's more of an experience where you're watching and there's much less gameplay. I would have liked to be able to steer the story and force us to constantly make choices. At some point it became a simulator where you just walk around and taste the atmosphere. While the level designs were incredible at this point, they didn't adequately cover up the shortcomings of the overall game. It could have been a perfect game after five years, but as it is, it's lacking. It's still a better experience than the first game, but it lacks variety. I liked it and found some of the scenes impressive and despite its shortcomings it's above average.

This game is a masterpiece. The puzzles are much better, more varied, more enjoyable than in the first game.

The atmosphere is very impressive. The horror of the sounds, the chaotic side of the atmosphere, the presence of music in some moments and interactions, this really made me feel inside the game.

Obviously, the twist in the story was also successful. It took me back and forth between truth and lies, love and hate. The unique behaviors and actions of the characters did not go against the flow of the game. Obviously, they did not leave me alone on this path I walked with them, I had fun with their dialogues. Sometimes they left me with question marks, sometimes they just told me the truth, sometimes they left me in a dilemma. I want to say that it was an enjoyable experience, and the logic of the portal is taken to a whole new level here, it's really close to perfection. I knew it would be much better than the first game.

I say again, this game is a masterpiece and please Valve, don't hate the number 3 so much...

I don't know where to start, but this is definitely an below average game. Honestly, there were a lot of things I didn't like about the game and very few things I liked. What I liked about the game: The atmosphere, the weapon designs and variety, the inherent enemy design and variety.

I have to say the following about the things I liked because they are also lacking in their own right. The atmosphere looks good, but it feels hollow. The weapon designs and variety are good, but the combat is incredibly bland and boring. Enemy design and variety is good, but they are incredibly frustrating and the constant hit and run is tiring. There's no soul in the things they do well.

The game is frankly unnecessarily fast but not enjoyable. I hated the stupid glove that talked to me while the character was walking fast. I had to stop to read the dialog and I couldn't even feel the surroundings because he was talking so much. The shooting feel is very weak and unpleasant. The most useless open world game. It would have been better if it went in a linear direction. Not every game has to be open world. I witnessed them killing a potential and I was really patient with this game but no, it makes absolutely no sense and will not leave a trace in my mind.

It's a constant conversation and I wanted them to stop talking and I wanted to play the game a little bit but no, it's just a soulless production that wants to tell a lot but can't tell and in the end it doesn't make you feel anything, if they learn from the mistakes, the next work will be much better.

It's a strange gaming experience, frankly. I didn't expect this journey to get so complicated in the first place, and even though I love the art design, the sounds and the music, I felt a bit bad that I was struggling to understand something along the way. What was I supposed to make of it? I felt something more than that. The artwork was so strange that I realized when I got to the end of the game that it actually managed to hypnotize me. But in the end I would have liked to understand something, so I went online and got some information, and yes, the game doesn't tell as complex a story as it seems, it presents a simple story at an astronomical level, so I can't say I was bored, but I want to make it clear that my mind was tired.

Yes, it may be a very deep game, but I wanted the depth to be understood on the surface. In this era of game uniformity, I will continue to test the different experiences that games like this provide. For me, it will remain the strangest game I've played this year.