Reviews from

in the past


Fantastic mechanics, fine ending

Nemesis system is literally one of the coolest systems in a game and they trademarked it and never used it again

An amazing experience of a game, the story twists and turns, and the nemesis system is greatly improved. My only problem is how long this game is, I've beaten the original 6 times and this one only once because of how daunting it is

Didn't play the first game but instantly fell got engrossed in the nemesis system. Didn't care much for the story, maybe because I didn't play the first one. The nemesis system provided so much replayability, generating its own stories. Heavily Underrated


Doesn't change enough from the original

While the game grows in every way from the first, it also grows in bugs. Lots of sprinting and wall-scaling bugs that bricked my console more than a few times. Excellent story with even better combat.

gotta love mee british brutes! mingin mates they is, an army of the fellows

Platinum Trophy - Not perfect, but damn if it isn’t great. It’s a crime that the nemesis system has been taken away from us since this game dropped, It’s so addicting, nothing else comes close. This is a comfort game for me, and it’ll always hold a special place in my heart.

This review contains spoilers

i love the conquering castle concept and having an army/Captain, just sucks that the equipment for defending and attacking costs so much :)

Gameplay overshines the dissapointing ending. Its almost addicting, and it offers and experience like no other.

Mouais pas convaincu par le system de combat

One of my favorite games ever. Underrated.

more of the same it was fine
there were a lot of places this nemesis system could've evolved to but womp womp gotta push a sequel just a few years after

bom mas fica repetitivo dps de um tempo

I like capturing orcs and making them my friends.

there will never be a better lord of the rings game

i love building my own orc army

why is the story not just making the orc army

A very improved version of Shadow of Mordor and what was missing is the war mechanic and objectives. There are more varieties way of executions and finishers which I loved in a game, more expanded version of the nemesis system which is my most favorite from the game, and a very expanded location with different locations and cities. I actually found myself really drawn into the story. Yes, there are a lot of things canonically wrong, but I find the story is in many ways more interesting the same as a Tolkien story as LOTR fan. It can get a little repetitve as you grind as you spend a lot of hours in this game you will still enjoy the large content the game has to offer.

DLC Blade of Galadriel
- This was a nice little piece of bonus content, but there wasn't really anything new or exciting here. Eltariel's Light abilities were interesting but I still cant enjoy playing her after what she did from the main protagonist.

DLC Desolation of Mordor
- A new innovative DLC with a lot of new content with a refreshing gameplay and new locations. As you play a human with grounded combat features that makes the combat quite enjoyable and rewarding

Si te gusta matar orcos de diversas formas está muy bien, ahora aviso que casi cualquier cosa fuera de ahí estaba mejor hecho en el primero. El defender fortalezas es tremendamente aburrido, las IAs acompañantes dan vergüenza, y si quieres tener buenos orcos tienes que ponerlos a luchar entre ellos en aburridísimas peleas sin sentido ninguno. Aun así lo recomiendo si tienes eso en cuenta. Eso y que el juego acaba y luego hay como un post game raro donde debes defender fortalezas que es un mierdón.

I can't give it a higher score than the first because of the absolutely atrocious end game that it first launched with. Luckily I played it after everything had been patched out and fixed, but imagining how long that would take to grind gave me second hand exhaustion.
That being said, leading assaults on castles was incredible, and the nemesis system gave me some amazing stories. Had one dude who just wouldn't die and followed me to the ends of the earth until he was killed by a troll for good. RIP that guy.


This review contains spoilers

Got this off of Xbox Gamepass during the Covid lockdown and it really had me hooked. Gameplay isn't nothing ground breaking, and can get really repetitive, but despite that I kept playing and enjoying myself. The nemesis system that makes procedurally generated bosses keeps the game fresh and interesting, and gives you a Pokémon like feeling as you catch and dominate orcs and make your army. The story though nothing amazing at first redeemed itself in the later half, and talion is still one of my favorite protagonists ever. Although his fate was also tragic, it was nice seeing him get peace at the end.

Free PS plus game. Had no idea this was from the makers of F.E.A.R. Pretty fun from what I played. Just an Arkham clone though.

Shadow of War is yet another fun free-flow combat open-world game set in the Lord of the Rings universe/lore. I really enjoyed the first game (Shadow of Mordor) and I had once again fun playing this follow-up even though I'm not into the story and/or lore of the LOTR universe.

Personally, it's the free-flow combat system that kept me engaged in this game along with some other mechanics that are part of this series such as the nemesis system, stronghold takes, army building, etc.

This game had a rough and controversial launch and early life due to microtransactions and pay-to-win mechanics that apparently have been removed or at least improved later on so I'm glad I decided to play this game many years after its release.

While this game did not have the 'wow' factor that I experienced with Shadow of Mordor, it remains a fun game for most of its duration as long as you are able to learn all the ins and outs of the free-flow combat system.
Admittedly, the gameplay can become a bit stale and repetitive since it's a longer than a normal game, and some mission quests (such as Carnan) are overall bland and poorly designed but for the most part the game is solid and has enough content to provide a good experience.

Not the best game but after reading the LOTR it is solid fun