Not without its issues (The Miles Morales storyline and some narrative decisions in the third act are a little sketchy) but this is easily the best game in the series just on a gameplay level alone.

Insomniac can sometimes struggle to tell an engaging story all the way through to the end, but man, they consistently nail those big emotional moments every single time. The side stories here are wonderful and show just how the developers love and understand what Spider-Man should symbolise as a character. Yuri Lowenthal also absolutely nails the role of Peter once again.

One step forward. Two steps back.

Better than Fallout 4 but far from Bethesda's peak. For every fun component here (campaign, space fights, companions), it's bogged down with confounding designs on a fundamental level that seeks to let the game down at every turn. I had a lot of fun with this one despite my problems but man, Bethesda really need to start remembering why their games work so well. It's not about the "Legendary" weapons and the never-ending radiant quests. It's about exploring a hand-crafted space and seeing what secrets the devs have hidden within. Bigger isn't always better. What fun is there in exploring thousands of planets when the majority of them are completely empty or stuffed with the same three outposts?

A fascinating misfire. The atmosphere you'd somewhat expect from Amnesia is still present and accounted for but the sanity, tinderboxes and the tension of your lantern running out are pretty much completely gone in lieu of something more akin to a walking simulator.

For the record, I'm a big walking sim guy but here, it's easily where the main problems of the game lie. For about 2-3 hours or so of the five-hour length, this is a deeply boring game with shockingly easy puzzles and a story you can spot the twist of a mile away. However, once the machine of 'A Machine for Pigs' rears its head, the game picks up substantially and really begins to have fun with itself with multiple sequences offering some much-needed tension.

It's bizarre that this is even an Amnesia game as so many links of that series are almost cut out entirely but as it stands, it's a fascinating game to play through and think about not in terms of what the game has to offer but more so how strange this was to release around the same time you'd expect a mainline sequel to the first Amnesia game to come around. Making a spin-off that rips out most of what Amnesia what it was is a strange choice but to do it essentially at the peak of the actual franchise is even stranger.